Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
---|---|
#1methvezemJan 11, 2006 17:45:11 | First of all, Happy New Year to you all! This is the first in a series of 3 PrC that I will post in the coming days. I ask you to give me your comments for them, if you will. So here it goes: (and thanks Pennarin for the editing) Slave-Warrior “My life is worth nothing if I let harm come to my masters.” - Ampelos, family Mericles’ slave-warrior Merchant houses and noble families regularly single out promising youth from amongst the ranks of their slaves, training them as warriors and preparing them for the labyrinthine laws and politics of the athasian cities. Those slave-warriors protect more than the lives of their masters, extending their protection to their master's interests and holdings, often venturing within the rarefied realms only accountants and templars tread. The brutal indoctrination regiment of their youth and the excellent combat training they receive produces some of the most dedicated warriors on Athas. Privileged in the knowledge they are taught and the responsibilities they are given, slave-warriors are reputed as incorruptible. They act as bodyguards, enforcers, and ruthless middlemen ready to sacrifice their lives for their masters'. The ranks of the slave-warriors are mostly taken up by fighters and warriors, some with a few levels of expert. Members of any race, as long as raised into slavery from birth, can be found as slave-warriors; thri-kreen and aarakocra are some of the hardest races to bring up in this fashion. NPC slave-warriors are found anywhere their masters travel, protecting them from harm at home or on caravans across the wastes. They also can be found making errands for their masters, or acting as collectors or supervisors as their loyalty is proverbial. They are usually prominently branded or tattooed with the emblem of their owning house. Hit Die: d10. Requirements: To qualify to become a slave-warrior, a character must fulfill all the following criteria. Base attack bonus: +3. Skills: Diplomacy or Intimidate 1 rank, Knowledge (local) 2 ranks, Sense Motive 2 ranks. Special: Must be born a slave. Special: Must currently be owned by the same master, household, or organization that has owned him from birth. Class Skills: The slave-warrior’s class skills (and the key ability for each skill) are Climb (Str), Diplomacy (Cha), Handle Animal (Cha), Intimidate (Cha), Jump (Str), Knowledge (local) (Int), Ride (Dex), and Sense Motive (Cha). Skill Points at Each Level: 2 + Int modifier. |
#2zombiegleemaxJan 11, 2006 17:52:04 | haha, nice icon...i thought i was the only one that had this one (damn) The prc...not bad, nice touch with the equipment...but i would have to lean against the devotion ability...but that's me...Still, i'm voting a well deserved two thumbs up |
#3kalthandrixJan 11, 2006 21:18:33 | Simple and beautiful Meth :D I will have to make up my damn Lion's Guard soon so I can use your slave warrior PrC to make up some really sweet bodyguards for Hamanu. The things I would make a suggested fix to is the following After having survived during their childhood a brutal training regime and incessant indoctrination, they become some of the most highly skilled fighters on Athas. The underlined part is not really a smooth read IMO and the first paragraph may need some additional tweeking to make it just right. The devotion is cool, but a +3 bonus is a bit high IMO for a three level PrC. And it is a generic bonus- I personally think it would be better off at a morale bonus. And I realize that you want to keep the lvl of those taking this PrC down slightly, but a +1 BAB to take this class. That does not strike me as being "some of the most highly skilled fighters on Athas" or something that would require "a brutal training regime and incessant indoctrination". Maybe a +3 BAB would sell that a bit more. Anyway...great job and I am looking forward to seeing the other two PrC's- I will promise to give you some good feedback on those ones too. |
#4methvezemJan 12, 2006 8:04:49 | haha, nice icon...i thought i was the only one that had this one (damn) hehe, I always was fond of the old Advanced Dungeon & Dragons DMG's cover The prc...not bad, nice touch with the equipment...but i would have to lean against the devotion ability...but that's me... Could you explain why you would lean against the devotion ability? The underlined part is not really a smooth read IMO and the first paragraph may need some additional tweeking to make it just right. Sorry about my english but its already better than what I can do alone. I had it corrected and I'm glad you didn't see my first draft ;) The devotion is cool, but a +3 bonus is a bit high IMO for a three level PrC. And it is a generic bonus- I personally think it would be better off at a morale bonus. That is a great suggestion, I'll add the morale type to the bonus, it's really adequate. And I realize that you want to keep the lvl of those taking this PrC down slightly, but a +1 BAB to take this class. That does not strike me as being "some of the most highly skilled fighters on Athas" or something that would require "a brutal training regime and incessant indoctrination". Maybe a +3 BAB would sell that a bit more. Perhaps I should have written trained in place of skilled and warrior in place of fighter. I based myself off the slave-warrior kit from the Dragon 194 magazine. I first did a write-up as substitution levels for the fighter class, which I found as more appropriate for this concept, but as these are not OGL, I rewrote it as a PrC. I will post it as substitution level in my next post so you can see and tell me which version you prefer and/or use. |
#5SysaneJan 12, 2006 8:21:42 | Nice little PrC you have here. Good job. I agree with Kal on the bonus being a little high. Even with it being labled a moral bonus I think it should be brought to a +2. |
#6methvezemJan 12, 2006 8:45:48 | After reflection, +3 is a little high for a 3 level PrC. I kept the last modifier (+3) of the third substitution level while formatting into a PrC. Perhaps I should have kept the second (+2). I will post the substitution levels here in this thread later today, so you'll see that the abilities were more appropriate for the level they were gained. |
#7shimJan 12, 2006 9:24:32 | This PrC looks nice, but I think it is a bit overpowered. Furthermore the requirements are very low for such a powerful prestige class. Most prestige classes require at least level 6 to enter. Fanaticism (Su): At 3rd level, the slave-warrior’s single-mindedness gives him a +4 bonus on saves to resist mind-affecting and compulsion effects. This is almost a +4 on will as most will saves are to resist mind-affecting effects. This is quite heavy! Especially when you take into account the +3 "devotion" bonus, you could have a +7 bonus total. As most Slave Warriors are probably always on duty, they always have these bonusses. Maybe it is better to tune it down to a +2 The devotion is cool, but a +3 bonus is a bit high IMO for a three level PrC. And it is a generic bonus- I personally think it would be better off at a morale bonus. Indeed. Maybe +2 (morale bonus) is better. I also cannot imagine why the Slave Warrior gets a bonus on reflex saves. Maybe "devotion +1" should be a +1 to hit and +1 to will (and maybe fortitude) saves. [Edit: oops I let the window open for 1 hour. Someone was before me :P] Reputed Loyalty (Ex): The slave-warriors are well-known as powerful, single-minded warriors that would give their lives for their masters. They gain a +2 competence bonus to Bluff, Diplomacy, and Intimidate checks. "Diplomacy" and "Bluff" as class skills for a slave sounds strange to me. This sounds more like an agent or something. |
#8darksoulmanJan 12, 2006 9:41:05 | This PrC looks nice, but I think it is a bit overpowered. Quite so, this is even official: When you design a prestige class, make sure that characters must be at least 5th level before they can meet the entry requirements [i.e. first PrC level at 6]. Of course, nothing stops you from ignoring this completely in your own campaign. Gaining recognition for a PrC outside that, however, is going to be harder if you ignore the rules |
#9PennarinJan 12, 2006 11:59:25 | "Diplomacy" and "Bluff" as class skills for a slave sounds strange to me. This sounds more like an agent or something. I came to the same conclusion, but Meth explained to me that the slave-warrior is indeed an agent/messenger/interface for his master, due to his exceptional fluff loyalty. I tend to think its a good idea. Mmm, in the earlier version of this PrC Bluff was replaced with Sense Motive so the slave could peceive lies and harmful intent... When you design a prestige class, make sure that characters must be at least 5th level before they can meet the entry requirements [i.e. first PrC level at 6]. I guess that a +5 BAB would do it. |
#10SysaneJan 12, 2006 12:04:34 | I came to the same conclusion, but Meth explained to me that the slave-warrior is indeed an agent/messenger/interface for his master, due to his exceptional fluff loyalty. I tend to think its a good idea. After that explanation I think Sense Motive is actually a better fit for the PrC. |
#11zombiegleemaxJan 12, 2006 14:52:44 | if i recall correctly, i don't think the purple dragon knight has very high requirements...could be wrong The devotion ability i was against simply because it was darn powerful. Cool ideas given to the prestige class though; i like the idea behind it.... |
#12PennarinJan 12, 2006 15:45:26 | Ok, considering the Purple Dragon Knight PrC, the following requirements could be better: Base attack bonus: +4. Skills: Diplomacy or Intimidate 1 rank, Sense Motive 2 ranks. Special: Must be born a slave. Special: Must currently be owned by the same master, household, or organization that has owned him from birth. |
#13kalthandrixJan 12, 2006 15:45:46 | I personally think Diplomacy abd Bluff very improtant skills for any slave related PrC- it helps them get some additional food, better clothing, fast talking a guardsman out of reporting their activities- I just do not think you are looking at those skills and how they would relate to a slave-based class. I think that this class as substitute levels for a fighter or warrior would be right on- I would like to see both versions. Like I said, I will be using this class to do some write-ups on some of the Half-giant's in plan on using with my Lion's Guard PrC (it is in the works- I got a bit done yesterday and today so I should be finished soon). |
#14ruhl-than_sageJan 12, 2006 18:20:26 | I can see how this was a level subsitution scheme and I think it would make more sense in that format. I'd love to see it outlined that way. Replaces levels 1, 2, & 4 I would guess.... What's up with the Ref and Will saving throws? +0, +1, +2? I don't follow how your coming up with that. |
#15PennarinJan 12, 2006 18:44:58 | Substitution levels are really great, but not OGC, why Meth graciously decided to offer the community a potentially-official morcel from his brain, even though he already completed the progression for the slave-warrior substitution levels. For more ideas on what a similar 3 level PrC can do, check out Libris Mortis' Death's Chosen, I think its called. The saves appear to be typing errors. |
#16methvezemJan 12, 2006 18:54:14 | Diplomacy and Sense Motive are more adequate as skills for the class as Pennarin explained above. I put a bonus in Bluff but as Sysane said, Sense Motive is more adequate. DarkSoulman, I agree with you about the requirements for PrC. You can read the others PrCs I've made to see that such as not escaped my attention. As I've said above, I designed first the slave-warrior as substitution levels, which is more fitting to the theme IMO. The requirements written by Pennarin looks good to make the class more balanced. As Shim mentionned, the bonuses for the fanaticism ability is more appropriate for the level if they are a +2. And finally yes, the Ref and Will save are typos, they also come from the substitution levels... Here is the slave-warrior as substitution levels (I already integrated change based on your comments): Slave-Warrior substitution levels “My life is worth nothing if I let harm come to my masters.” - Ampelos, family Mericles’ slave-warrior Merchant houses and noble families regularly single out promising youth from amongst the ranks of their slaves, training them as warriors and preparing them for the labyrinthine laws and politics of the athasian cities. Those slave-warriors protect more than the lives of their masters, extending their protection to their master's interests and holdings, often venturing within the rarefied realms only accountants and templars tread. The brutal indoctrination regiment of their youth and the excellent combat training they receive produces some of the most dedicated warriors on Athas. Privileged in the knowledge they are taught and the responsibilities they are given, slave-warriors are reputed as incorruptible. They act as bodyguards, enforcers, and ruthless middlemen ready to sacrifice their lives for their masters'. Members of any race, as long as raised into slavery from birth, can be found as slave-warriors; thri-kreen and aarakocra are some of the hardest races to bring up in this fashion. NPC slave-warriors are found anywhere their masters travel, protecting them from harm at home or on caravans across the wastes. They also can be found making errands for their masters, or acting as collectors or supervisors as their loyalty is proverbial. They are usually prominently branded or tattooed with the emblem of their owning house. Hit Die: d10. Requirements: To take a level of Slave-Warrior fighter substitution level, a character must be born a slave be owned by a master, household, or organization, and still be at the service of the same master, household, or organisation, and be about to take his 1st, 4th, or 8th level of fighter. Class Skills: Slave-Warrior substitution levels have the class skills of the standard fighter class plus Diplomacy, Knowledge (local) and Sense Motive. Skill Points at Each Level: 2 + Int modifier. |
#17PennarinJan 12, 2006 19:48:06 | Here is my proposed rewrite to bring the slave-warrior more in line with its true functions.Merchant houses and noble families regularly single out promising youth from amongst the ranks of their slaves, training them as warriors and preparing them for the labyrinthine laws and politics of the athasian cities. Those slave-warriors protect more than the lives of their masters, extending their protection to their master's interests and holdings, often venturing within the rarefied realms only accountants and templars tread. The brutal indoctrination regiment of their youth and the excellent combat training they receive produces some of the most dedicated warriors on Athas. Privileged in the knowledge they are taught and the responsibilities they are given, slave-warriors are reputed as incorruptible. They act as bodyguards, enforcers, and ruthless middlemen ready to sacrifice their lives for their masters'. |
#18ruhl-than_sageJan 13, 2006 1:36:37 | thri-kreen cannot be brought up in this fashion. :D Can aarakocra or half-giants? |
#19kalthandrixJan 13, 2006 5:58:32 | I would hope H-G's could, but I really do not see aarakocra being very good choices for this PrC. |
#20methvezemJan 13, 2006 8:30:30 | :D Can aarakocra or half-giants? I guess its a matter of DM's call as are the availability of any PrC. I changed the introduction text to make it so that even kreen can become slave-warrior. Half-giants most certainly do. Thanks Penn for the new introduction. It is more in line with what I envisionned the slave-warrior to be. I edited the PrC to reflect the feedback I received. I now think it is more balanced for a 3 level PrC. Please take a look and tell me if it is really so. I personally think Diplomacy abd Bluff very improtant skills for any slave related PrC- it helps them get some additional food, better clothing, fast talking a guardsman out of reporting their activities- I just do not think you are looking at those skills and how they would relate to a slave-based class. I'm agreeing with you here. I changed it in the PrC because of its elite status and loyalty in comparaison to the average slave. See the new description and you'll understand ;) |
#21PennarinJan 13, 2006 14:01:50 | Might as well make the following changes: The ranks of the slave-warriors are mostly taken up by fighters and warriors, some with a few levels of expert. Members of any race, as long as raised into slavery from birth, can be found as slave-warriors; thri-kreen and aarakocra are some of the hardest races to bring up in this fashion. |
#22kalthandrixJan 13, 2006 14:46:20 | I like it- it keeps the option open to make a really unique character or NPC, but does make it clear that deviations from the norm are very rare. |
#23methvezemJan 13, 2006 17:25:36 | Might as well make the following changes: Thanks and done. :D |
#24PennarinJan 15, 2006 6:01:00 | Fanaticism (Su): At 3rd level, the slave-warrior’s single-mindedness gives him a +2 bonus on saves to resist mind-affecting and compulsion effects if said effect goes against the slave-warrior's loyalty. Dunno if this is a good idea, but alternatives to the bonus might be to get an immediate second save in case of a failure, or a save when none is permited. |
#25methvezemJan 15, 2006 7:06:23 | You think the +2 bonus should be something else if it pertains to the slave-warrior's loyalty? Something he can do once per day (for exemple)? |
#26nytcrawlrJan 15, 2006 8:34:28 | Ok, excuse my ignorance, but where are these so called substitution levels coming from? What book was this brought up in? Thanks. |
#27methvezemJan 15, 2006 9:34:35 | I'm not sure in which book exatly they were introduced, but I think its in the Races series. At first the substitution levels were for adapting a class to a racial theme e.g. a dwarven tunnel fighter so you have a regular dwarf who is classed as a fighter but at specific levels can take the said substitution levels. Now, with the Heroes series (for the FR), the substitution levels can be used for adapting a class to a certain organization. When I first begun working on the slave-warrior, it was as a 'human' racial substiution levels since those were the only ones I was aware at the time. Between the time I begun the levels and I finished them, a couple of months passed and I became aware of the 'organization' substitution levels, so I reworked them to fit this new model. After that, I made it a PrC (with all its errors ) since the substitution levels are not OGC. |
#28PennarinJan 15, 2006 18:57:44 | I think substitution levels first appeared in the Planar Handbook, along with touchstones. Both were called, at the time, planar substitution levels and planar touchstones, predictably. |