What realy happened with Chaos?

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 20:46:09
Dragon of Summer Flame and post War of Souls spoiler

S
P
O
I
L
E
R

S
P
A
C
E

I everyone, I be soon starting a new DL campaign, and I'd liked to have your opinion on something.

After Chaos's defeat, Fizban told Palin that the gods had made a deal with Chaos to leave Krynn if he'd do the same...
At the end of DoaVM and/or in the Campaign setting, we learn that it was Takhisis who was impersonating Fizban...was there a deal with Chaos or not...

At the end of DoSF, Usha managed to catch a drop of Chaos blood within the Graygem trapping Chaos back into the gem.

My intention for my game is to use the Graygem. The gem will be in the tower of Wareth, somwhere realy realy deep, well guarded. I've tought of three way to explain it's location :

#1-The three gods of magic put it there (if they had time to do so, if not they'll use Tas's leap in time with the transportation ability of the tower).

#2-Takhisis put it there herself for safekeeping, and maybe futur use.

#3-The Graygem moved there by itself.

What do you think of this???
#2

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 20:56:56
Nah
#4- Reorx lost it in a game of bones with one of the wizards.
#3

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:08:18
:invasion: :pile: :bounce: lol!
Good one!
Right on caracter!
#4

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:12:40
Actually I thought I saw Chaos the other morning working at the local 7/11. He was getting hassled by his duty manager for being late and that guy looked a lot like Elvis... ;)

Arandur
#5

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:19:23
#5 Reorx lost it after getting drunk with some dwaves.
#6

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:30:01
#6-Lunitari wanted it back, but then the Krynn got away.
#7

baron_the_curse

Sep 09, 2003 21:34:35
Did the authors really planned from the beginning Takhisis stealing the world? Or are they just fixing what was broken. An un-consisted timeline.
#8

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:41:50
They are probably fixing up, but still, a god who can take all the others with his hands binded behind it's back does'nt disapear that easily.
#9

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:45:10
I think the idea of Takhisis impersonating Fizban and lying about the "deal" is much better than the way DoSF ended. If Chaos was once again imprisoned in the Gem, why the heck would the gods have to make a deal with him? He was beaten.

If Chaos gets to come out if the gods don't agree to leave, its not much of a prison now is it? As wild as it is, Takhisis stealing the world immediately after the victory against Chaos makes much more sense than the gods all leaving for fear of a being that is no longer a threat to them.
#10

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 21:48:40
I agree, still...Chaos was'nt sucked up in the gem, he was still there.
#11

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 22:25:02
My memory's a bit hazy on the finale of DoSF...didn't the drop of blood that was captured in the Gem cause Chaos to be imprisoned? If not then what was the point of getting the blood?
#12

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 22:26:05
So what is the answer? Is chaos still loose? or is he back the the graystone?
#13

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 22:35:23
That is one of the many questions i'm looking to find answers to by posting on this message board. I can't believe that with all the sages on this board I won't find those answers...maybe we should invite Astinus to shed some light on the questions???
#14

baron_the_curse

Sep 09, 2003 22:58:15
What made Chaos more poweful than the other Greater Deities? It almost seem as if Chaos was as poweful as the High God.
#15

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 23:14:31
Originally posted by Baron the Curse
What made Chaos more poweful than the other Greater Deities? It almost seem as if Chaos was as poweful as the High God.

Chaos is beyond Greater God level, much like Ao in Greyhawk (or is Ao in Faerun?). His power is unmeasurable.
#16

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 23:17:22
Hi. Jacen's brother Kell speaking. Too lazy to sign out my younger bro.

Anyway, before the War of Souls, I was under the impression that Chaos had put a LOT of his power into manifesting himself on Krynn...remember those two or three times Takky tried/did? Anyway, I thought that they had imprisoned Chaos's PHYSICAL form, and all the power wrapped up in it, and that the gods dealed with a weaker, more beatable Chaos. Either that, or he was TOTALLY re-imprisoned, and the gods decided to deal with him right then, instead of going through Chaos vs. Everyone Else Round 2, when he inevitably broke loose again.

After reading WoS though...well, I guess that Chaos was trapped, and the gods threw him in a closet or something.

Oh, and, about Summer Flame and the War of Souls...though I DID enjoy them a lot...I was strangely and vaguely disappointed after reading them. They just didn't FEEL like the work I'd come to know and love from the DL team. Raistlin just seemed so...deus ex machina, appearing YET AGAIN to haul the gods collective rears out of the fire, Mina turning from the uber-cool religious fanatic to some psychopathic kinda person (which she did not play very well, in my opinion), the Dark Knight Archer guy just kinda disappearing after Lost Star (yeah, I know, he was put in charge of something or another, but still!), the almost deus ex machina of Paladine coming in with that "I'll turn mortal to turn YOU mortal!" thing that really instead of surprising me into shock and awe made me wonder what the heck was going through their brains, the tale of the creation of the world and everything set down by Paladine at the end, etc. etc. etc...the list just goes on. They were good books. Don't get me wrong. And Fallen Sun and Lost Star were REALLY good books. But...in the end, that's all they were. Just good.
#17

zombiegleemax

Sep 09, 2003 23:19:38
Oh, and sorry about getting so off-topic. I just kinda tend to ramble on and on sometimes. I'd always wanted to say that though. Please continue with your convo!

Oh, and...

7) Reorx got drunk and lost it in a game of bones with Lunitari who was disguised as a dwarven mage. But then Takky nicked Krynn. Beat that! : P
#18

baron_the_curse

Sep 10, 2003 0:36:42
While I agree that is better to say Takhisis stole the world and impersonated Fizban at the end of the Chaos War (which I don’t buy for one second) can someone tell me who the hell impersonated Raistlin at the end of the Summer of Flame? He did depart with the Gods.
#19

iltharanos

Sep 10, 2003 0:54:40
Originally posted by Baron the Curse
While I agree that is better to say Takhisis stole the world and impersonated Fizban at the end of the Chaos War (which I don’t buy for one second) can someone tell me who the hell impersonated Raistlin at the end of the Summer of Flame? He did depart with the Gods.

Takhisis. If she can create an image of Fizban, then creating an image of Raistlin at the same time shouldn't be too hard to pull off. Since Takhisis had already stolen the world at that point, it's not as if another God will pop up and admonish Takhisis for image copyright violations.
#20

baron_the_curse

Sep 10, 2003 1:10:20
Or that never really happened. Come on, that was never planned from the beginning. It's fair to say Hickman and Weis actually intended to end it that way. That was Fizban and Raist. I would have rather that scene was erased from history rather than claiming it was an impersonation. I personally didn’t like Dragons of Summer Flame. It was a marketing ploy to destroy the world of Krynn, as we know it to prepare it for the coming of the Fifth Age products. Which in turn was just another ploy to sale us the Saga System.
#21

iltharanos

Sep 10, 2003 1:17:00
**crosses fingers**

Here's to hoping there won't be yet another SAGA sucks vs. SAGA doesn't suck debate.
#22

zombiegleemax

Sep 10, 2003 5:44:16
What made Chaos more poweful than the other Greater Deities? It almost seem as if Chaos was as poweful as the High God.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------



chaos and the high-god, is chaos not the high-god???
#23

jonesy

Sep 10, 2003 6:10:33
Originally posted by FOXDIE
What made Chaos more poweful than the other Greater Deities?

That's almost like asking what makes a cat stronger than mice. More strength/power.

As for the High God, I don't think that his level of power can even be measured against the other gods. What he wants, happens. And what he wants, no one can be sure of.
#24

talinthas

Sep 10, 2003 13:53:12
remember that, before dovm, chaos and the high god were basically the same. two parts of one. father of all and nothing, and all that.
#25

sweetmeats

Sep 10, 2003 15:37:09
If Reorx stuck Chaos in the Graygem in the first place, why couldn't he do it again?
#26

Dragonhelm

Sep 10, 2003 16:14:27
Originally posted by talinthas
remember that, before dovm, chaos and the high god were basically the same. two parts of one. father of all and nothing, and all that.

I know that was my perception at the time, but Tracy has said that the two were never meant to be the same.
#27

Dragonhelm

Sep 10, 2003 16:24:54
Originally posted by Baron the Curse
Or that never really happened. Come on, that was never planned from the beginning. It's fair to say Hickman and Weis actually intended to end it that way. That was Fizban and Raist. I would have rather that scene was erased from history rather than claiming it was an impersonation. I personally didn’t like Dragons of Summer Flame. It was a marketing ploy to destroy the world of Krynn, as we know it to prepare it for the coming of the Fifth Age products. Which in turn was just another ploy to sale us the Saga System.

Summer Flame was intended moreso as the end story of DL. At the time, they didn't think it would go on.
#28

baron_the_curse

Sep 10, 2003 16:27:01
Originally posted by jonesy
That's almost like asking what makes a cat stronger than mice. More strength/power.

As for the High God, I don't think that his level of power can even be measured against the other gods. What he wants, happens. And what he wants, no one can be sure of.

No, that’s not like asking that at all. For one, Reorx trapped Chaos once already. Secondly, he was defeated by anarmy of mortals and a Kender. An army of mice has nothing on a single wild cat. So try not to be too patronizing.
#29

jonesy

Sep 10, 2003 16:35:20
Originally posted by Baron the Curse
No, that’s not like asking that at all. For one, Reorx trapped Chaos once already. Secondly, he was defeated by anarmy of mortals and a Kender. An army of mice has nothing on a single wild cat. So try not to be too patronizing.

I didn't try to be patronizing. No, actually slash that. I never try to be patronizing.

Reorx suggested in DoSF that he didn't really trap Chaos, and that Chaos willingly entered Krynn inside the gem so he could wreak havoc on the world.

And it wasn't just an army of mortals and a kender. It was the entire world and its gods fighting against Chaos that drained his powers (and he wasted a lot of it summoning his minions and keeping up the weird weather patterns).
#30

baron_the_curse

Sep 10, 2003 18:57:09
The whole Chaos thing seems sketchy anyway. I really would like to know where Chaos is now since the ending of Summer Flame was altered.
#31

zombiegleemax

Sep 11, 2003 3:26:37
is the ending of Summer Flame altered.??????
#32

zombiegleemax

Sep 11, 2003 4:48:40
I've read this "Takhisis impersonating Paladine" thing in the DLCS, but I don't remember it ever actually being mentioned in the War of Souls books. Why would she have to impersonate Paladine? Why couldn't she just misplace Krynn after the gods left when they made their deal with Chaos?

It's not like the other gods ever got upset with Takhisis for trying to take over the world before. And all that stuff. I liked it better when I hadn't read this whole impersonation thing. I was hoping Raistlin was the One God, though. Stupid Takhisis. She ruins everything.
#33

frojas

Sep 11, 2003 7:33:53
I think that there was no deal with Chaos. The gods won. Chaos was imprisoned and things would go about as before. That much is clear from the future that Tas saw first. Where the Elven nations were unified, and Palin was the head of the White Robes (white robes implies WoHS which implies that the gods never left in the first future).

Takhisis impersonated Paladine (Fizban to be exact) so that she could tell Palin that the gods struck a deal and had to leave the world. Thus Palin, Dalamar, Goldmoon, and company wouldn't bother to try and look for them.

FR
#34

zombiegleemax

Sep 11, 2003 18:18:15
I have to say this is a more satisfying story
than when I read Summer Flame. Seemed wrong
that after having been gone so long and finally
returning to Krynn, the Gods would just up and
leave again, for whatever reason.

Were I on Krynn at this time, I'd be pretty
angry.
#35

zombiegleemax

Oct 10, 2003 2:09:07
i THINK THAT THIS IS AQUESTION THAT WE MIGHT NEVER KNOW THE ANSWER TO BECAUSE dOsF WAS MEANT TO BE THE LAST BOOK OF dl. T
#36

zombiegleemax

Oct 10, 2003 2:09:07
i THINK THAT THIS IS AQUESTION THAT WE MIGHT NEVER KNOW THE ANSWER TO BECAUSE dOsF WAS MEANT TO BE THE LAST BOOK OF dl. T
#37

zombiegleemax

Oct 10, 2003 2:15:25
What we need to remember is that Dragons of Summer Flame was meant to be the last DL book, the series and world was going top be eneded as a Dungeosn and Dragons world. The authors had to jam a trilogies worth of writing into a one shot. Thus, this is why the story is not always as good as it could have been. I hope that the answer to our querstions will be given out though.
#38

amon_hok

Oct 13, 2003 4:42:47
Humm i must have missed alot i stopped reading Dragon Lance after the gods left and all the Mighty dragons started creating the world to their will, It seemed to me to be a waste of an incredible world they had going on, Chaos i thought was a over power while the High god was like the universe or eternity, anyways the gods have returned? what books do i read to see them come back?
#39

shugi

Oct 13, 2003 11:08:29
That would be the War of Souls trilogy, which is available in your local bookstore now! :D
#40

zombiegleemax

Oct 13, 2003 18:33:38
gods really show up in Book 3 of the WoS. Dragons of Vanished Moon. Sargas is about as grumpy as a dwarf sitting on hot coals.... lol