How does a MC2 Orcwort athasian version apeal to you?? - Downloaded from the Wizards Community, all coding removed by Solauren

Post/Author/DateTime	Post
#1 jihun-nish Nov 29, 2003 17:27:23	I was resilient to post this but after receiving a reply to a personal message I had sent to an official from "Athas.org",and I quote: REPLY: It's an interesting idea. I initially discarded the orcwort on the basis that it would be a Green Age creature and I wanted a "modern" list. The lists I am doing are exclusive rather than inclusive (to keep it manageable), but your idea is very flavour rich. I'm not aware of any plans to adapt creatures other than those on the basic DS list but this kind of idea could still work very well. Have you thought about statting it out and posting it to the boards?
#2 jihun-nish Nov 30, 2003 0:53:52	Come on you guys, 10 views and no comment at all... At least tell me if it's a or a :thumbsdow . I know one of you at Athas.org like the idea. And what about you: thread readers??
#3 Kamelion Nov 30, 2003 9:57:49	Jihun-Nish, why not come up with statistics for your creature? This gives people something substantive to give feedback to. The idea is interesting but it's still just an idea. (As an aside, opinions shared over the wizards.com pm function are not athas.org's position - especially as I am a member of the monsters bureau and not, strictly speaking, a .org "official" ;). Also, it's good form to get someone's permission before quoting private messages. No worries in this instance as we're not exactly exchanging confidences or anything, but it's always nice to be polite and stuff...)
#4 jihun-nish Nov 30, 2003 15:12:57	Originally posted by Kamelion (As an aside, opinions shared over the wizards.com pm function are not athas.org's position - especially as I am a member of the monsters bureau and not, strictly speaking, a .org "official" ;). Also, it's good form to get someone's permission before quoting private messages. No worries in this instance as we're not exactly exchanging confidences or anything, but it's always nice to be polite and stuff...) Sorry, I thought you were a .org official. And as for the "private message quoted" I didn't mention your name but after reading a second time what you wrote to me, it's true that it's prety obvious that you wrote the message. I would like to apologies in this thread and it will never happen again for anyone..(who might send me private messages) As for the stats I'll post them shortly.
#5 Kamelion Dec 01, 2003 6:22:57	Cheers, Jihun-Nish. It's no biggie. I'm just being my usual picky, picky self Look forward to them stats...

Post/Author/DateTime

Post

jihun-nish

Nov 29, 2003 17:27:23

I was resilient to post this but after receiving a reply to a personal message I had sent to an official from "Athas.org",and I quote:

REPLY: It's an interesting idea. I initially discarded the orcwort on the basis that it would be a Green Age creature and I wanted a "modern" list. The lists I am doing are exclusive rather than inclusive (to keep it manageable), but your idea is very flavour rich. I'm not aware of any plans to adapt creatures other than those on the basic DS list but this kind of idea could still work very well. Have you thought about statting it out and posting it to the boards?

jihun-nish

Nov 30, 2003 0:53:52

Come on you guys, 10 views and no comment at all...
At least tell me if it's a

or a :thumbsdow .

I know one of you at Athas.org like the idea. And what about you: thread readers??

Kamelion

Nov 30, 2003 9:57:49

Jihun-Nish, why not come up with statistics for your creature? This gives people something substantive to give feedback to. The idea is interesting but it's still just an idea.

(As an aside, opinions shared over the wizards.com pm function are not athas.org's position - especially as I am a member of the monsters bureau and not, strictly speaking, a .org "official" ;). Also, it's good form to get someone's permission before quoting private messages. No worries in this instance as we're not exactly exchanging confidences or anything, but it's always nice to be polite and stuff...)

jihun-nish

Nov 30, 2003 15:12:57

Originally posted by Kamelion
(As an aside, opinions shared over the wizards.com pm function are not athas.org's position - especially as I am a member of the monsters bureau and not, strictly speaking, a .org "official" ;). Also, it's good form to get someone's permission before quoting private messages. No worries in this instance as we're not exactly exchanging confidences or anything, but it's always nice to be polite and stuff...)

Sorry, I thought you were a .org official.

And as for the "private message quoted" I didn't mention your name but after reading a second time what you wrote to me, it's true that it's prety obvious that you wrote the message. I would like to apologies in this thread and it will never happen again for anyone..(who might send me private messages)

As for the stats I'll post them shortly.

Kamelion

Dec 01, 2003 6:22:57

Cheers, Jihun-Nish. It's no biggie. I'm just being my usual picky, picky self

Look forward to them stats...