Post/Author/DateTime | Post |
---|---|
#1knightfallMar 28, 2004 15:23:13 | Cut & Paste! - KF72
|
#2nytcrawlrMar 28, 2004 15:36:58 | All I got to say is: What a freaking waste... |
#3PennarinMar 28, 2004 15:37:47 | -insert fingers into ears- la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la................ |
#4jon_oracle_of_athasMar 28, 2004 15:48:30 | Uhu. *notifies rest of athas.org* |
#5nightdruidMar 28, 2004 15:51:08 | Originally posted by NytCrawlr Just to satisfy my curiosity, why? Not disagreeing or anything (haven't seen the mag, nor intend to get it, actually), but anything you expected differently? ;) |
#6nytcrawlrMar 28, 2004 16:09:01 | It's too watered down for one... Though the 300 years helps us out, don't have to worry about slamming into each other's timelines anytime soon. |
#7Shei-NadMar 28, 2004 16:11:36 | Very interesting IMO... original approach to have advanced the timeline so fully. And interesting take on what will happen, though it would need some further explaining for events such as: Dregoth's ascension and why he was stopped after taking Raam, but still allowed to remain there. Though this outcome is certainly plausible with the right explanations. Its also interesting that dregoth seized power in Raam 2 centuries before what is described there, which would mean about 100 years after the Death of Kalak, and not 11 or so as Dregoth Ascending seems to indicate (from what I understand). Anyways, this could be adjusted, and in any case, I'd rather have world-shattering events NOT happen all within a dozen years... Atzetuk's Dragon Kingship is also noteworthy, as if I remember correctly, this youth was Neutral Good. However, corruption is a major theme in Dark Sun, no? Androphinis's return is definately going to happen in my campaign at somepoint, and I'm thinking of an adventure around that very theme actually. Hmm... The new races I'm very neutral to. I'd have to see them to better judge. Very interesting IMO. It gives an idea of how things would work out, and could provide some nice info for those in the Age of Heroes who manage to glimpse into the future in order to change it. I do think its pretty cool (in an evil way ) that the quick fall of sorcerer kings, giving a slight relief to the peoples of the Tyr Region who might even have hoped to get rid of them altogether, ended up right back the way it was, with the exception of Tyr, now the only beacon of freedom of the Tyr Region. Note that I'd probably still end up playing around the Death of Kalak anyways, but its still interesting reading. |
#8Shei-NadMar 28, 2004 16:21:15 | There's more, when reading comments on EN world from people with the magazine: In regards to Templars and Gladiators, there are no templars in the adventure, but the DM's Guide has a few as NPCs. They use the Cleric class to represent being templars, and can apparently multiclass normally (some low-level gate-guarding templars in Nibenay are Clr2/Psi2 (telepath). Gladiators never were mentioned as a class at all, so while they might still be a new class, I doubt it, given what we've seen. No templars, or rather templar class, as templars would simply seem to be clerics of a sorcerer-king. And this is quite puzzling: The dray never even get mentioned. Dregoth has living templars, and undead ones, but it seems to imply that the living ones are human (or at least of other "standard" races for Dark Sun). The example templar given is a high ranking (living) human one. For more clarification, undead walk Raam openly, side by side with the living, and Dregoth encourages the notion that death is merely a (minor) change in status, nothing more. Even if the living high ranking templar in Mon Adderath (sp?), the rest is quite strange, which dregoth being obsessed with dray before. Anyways... |
#9heretic_apostateMar 28, 2004 17:24:26 | What about the "Last Stand of..." adventure? I thought that was a Dark Sun adventure? |
#10nightdruidMar 28, 2004 17:49:43 | Originally posted by NytCrawlr Know the feeling... |
#11dawnstealerMar 28, 2004 17:50:02 | I, for one, am going to pick up the new issue and peruse it before passing judgements. Honestly, the description above sounds intriguing. |
#12flipMar 28, 2004 18:07:58 | Hrm. Something to note here: This is, in some core elements, a return to DS1. A removal of many of the changes (some would say the most distasteful bits) presented in the PP and DS2.
(Note that it says _over_ 200 years ago. Which really means that Dave's given us plenty of wiggle room on when Dregoth Ascending takes place, but ties us down a bit on how far it goes. |
#13beyowulfMar 28, 2004 18:16:01 | Originally posted by flip Wonder what happened to "the Messenger". |
#14nightdruidMar 28, 2004 18:23:20 | Originally posted by beyowulf Well, since Athas doesn't have any cows to mutilate or (much) wheat to leave fun crop-circles, I'd imagine they just got bored and left... |
#15zombiegleemaxMar 28, 2004 18:46:43 | but ties us down a bit on how far it goes. How so? Are you bound under terms to comply with the material presented in the articles and treat it as you would any other official product? If not, then by all means take it in the direction you had originally intended to. 200 years difference is still a long time to 'clean up the campaign' to keep it in line with the Dragon/Dungeon articles. |
#16flipMar 28, 2004 20:51:24 | Originally posted by Mach2.5 Note the "a bit" ... I didn't say that this suddenly threw great big shackles on us. Heck, it's actually less conflicting than I had thought it might be. Of course, the total rejection of the introductions of DS2 (introductions, not events) is ... jarring, I suppose. (CBtSS predates DS2) |
#17zmajMar 28, 2004 21:34:43 | No Kreen invasion... High Lord Rhan Thes-onel has finally returned! The evil Kreen must be stopped! Suddenly the Kreen have other things to worry about. The only way I see Dregoth stopping with Raam is if he suddenly find himself without his undead army or up against all the remaining SMs. That secret project Nibenay's been working on could be behind it. Maybe it takes out the undead army or makes it so that the Dray no longer breed true. Children born are human and Dregoth doesn't have the time to change every child into a Dray (always had Dregoth himself as the only one who could change a human into Dray). Maybe New Giustinal collapses burying the Dray and Dregoth barely makes it out himself. He slowly takes over Raam empowering the former templars of the city again. How Andropinis got out 800 years early I dunno.. probably something to do with maenads though I haven't been able to read thier description yet so I don't know how they might do it or why. In Draj maybe Oronis helped free the mind of Atzetuk but something went wrong. He was a bit peeved and started wiping out everyone who had tried to control him, and used Tec's notes to become a dragon. Kurn and Eldaarrich weren't very well known citystates and with Oronis's failure he could easily urge Kurn to withdraw again. Eldaarrich? Never did really leave thier isolation. Gonna have to get a copy and read it for myself :-) |
#18knightfallMar 28, 2004 21:48:38 | Originally posted by Heretic Apostate Yes, it is. I just didn't cut and paste that part. |
#19zombiegleemaxMar 28, 2004 23:00:33 | The only way I see Dregoth stopping with Raam is if he suddenly find himself without his undead army or up against all the remaining SMs. Which is perfectly reasonable. Urik could easily launch an army, as could Draj. A scissor based attack by the two of these cities, even if not neccessarily coordinated or united could certainly halt Dergoth's advances. CbtSS only gives Dergoth a few hundred dray at his beck and call. Not really a roaming war machine if you ask me. Raam is described as having the highest population of any city state with 35,000 people prior to the death of Abalach-Re. Even assuming that the civil wars that wrack the city after her death cut the population in half over the course of several years, that's still a hefty number of people to deal with, and the years of internal fighting would probably harden the people up quite a bit. I doubt the Dergoth would have so easy a time with Raam by itself, never mind the looming threat of the two nearest cities. Also, Nibenay isn't too far from Guistinal. While the head honcho is out trying to take over a city and hold off two other SKs, Nib's formidible forces could in turn sack Guistinal with ease, and follow through towards Raam, creating a 3-way assault. If Dergoth's forces haven't taken the city by this time, its curtains for our Dread Lord. If they have taken Raam and fortified themselves, the prior civil wars and predations by the various warlords would likely leave very little supplies with which to outlast a seige by three armies. Wow, sorry about the length. I didn't mean to do that, I swear ;) How Andropinis got out 800 years early I dunno.. probably something to do with maenads though I haven't been able to read thier description yet so I don't know how they might do it or why I've got Andropoinis ruling his former city-state from the future by sending back his mind and possessing/controlling people during the present. Major props to The Sleeping Imperium for the idea of ruling inabsentia. He's gone quite insane over the past 1,000 years though, and it shows. You don't mistake someone he's dominated. In Draj maybe Oronis helped free the mind of Atzetuk but something went wrong. He was a bit peeved and started wiping out everyone who had tried to control him, and used Tec's notes to become a dragon. I like the idea. Thanks much. |
#20AlzriusMar 29, 2004 2:05:12 | Originally posted by flip Honestly, the article doesn't even really deny the introductions from DS2 either. The Kreen Empire and Last Sea get very brief mentions, so they are still there (if you read my quoted post above, I try to make the distinction that the map of the Tablelands just doesn't show them, because its only of the Tablelands). Nothing, as far as I can see, is inherently contradicted at all, in terms of setting and story advancement. Now the mechanics...well...that could be a different story. |
#21flipMar 29, 2004 6:47:18 | Originally posted by Alzrius Sorry. I understood that, though reading what I wrote, that's not how it comes across. I should rephrase then. What I find jarring is the fact that everything introduced in DS2 is totally ignored (not rejected) ... Now the mechanics...well...that could be a different story. I'm not expecting anything there... |
#22zombiegleemaxMar 29, 2004 8:55:19 | 300 years into the future, huh? I like that. I like that a lot. All I can say is that I can't wait. It should be here by post today. |
#23Silverblade_The_EnchanterMar 29, 2004 14:52:20 | Hm, only problem I can see with this, is, if Tyr does not have a sorceror king, it better bloody be a nasty, chaotic place, or ruled by a non-SK tyrant...otherwise it becomes the "goody goody" spot where PCs can safely retreat..start with no hassles etc...which is *bad*. The joy of DS is that it is a *BRUTAL*, nasty, fight-for-survival millieu. Taking that away would ruin it. |
#24zombiegleemaxMar 29, 2004 16:32:17 | Tyr does not have a sorceror king, it better bloody be a nasty, chaotic place, or ruled by a non-SK tyrant...otherwise it becomes the "goody goody" spot where PCs can safely retreat..start with no hassles etc...which is *bad*. Better . . . does not mean good. I run Tyr minus Kalak. Former slaves are now street beggars starving away in droves. Disease runs rampant throughout the slum sections of the city. Corruption and dissention rule the upper echelons of power. The Vielled Alliance, having been semi-open publicly, now also vies for power. Without the templarate organizing patrols and militia, crime is very high. Most of my players would rather contest with the anarchy in Raam than have to deal with Tyr. At least in Raam, you can see them coming when they try to kill you. In Tyr, its more often a knife in the back. |
#25zombiegleemaxMar 29, 2004 19:36:56 | I agree that it seems watered down. Apparently they needed to cut the Dray out completely, because it does mention that Dregoth ruled the city, but if it has inhabitants, no one knows. I also do not like that Aztetuk can become a dragon-king and Andropinis can return, but there is no mention of Tithian or Sadira at all. I also fear for the rules themselves, since there is a Mul gladitor listed from Tyr who is simply a 6th level fighter. By making Templars just clerics of the dragon-kings, it takes away all the story that the class had and that athas.org put back into it with their conversion. I will take new Dark Sun material from anywhere but this stuff really does nothing for me. Even the pictures are inaccurate, as several people have full suits of metal armor in numerous depictions. Alemander |
#26Shei-NadMar 29, 2004 19:39:41 | hmm... I'll lower my expectations then... |
#27nytcrawlrMar 29, 2004 20:05:42 | Wow, this is just starting to lose more and more appeal for me, at least they could have gotten the armor thing right. Oh well, I've got a subscription to both mags so I'm going to get both of them, soon I hope, and will just take what little I can from it. At least the defiler rules were good. |
#28nightdruidMar 29, 2004 20:15:12 | What about the Tyr Storms? Have they stopped (or were even mentioned?) Wondering what sort of long-term damage did the Cerulean Storm had... |
#29nytcrawlrMar 29, 2004 20:28:13 | Originally posted by Nightdruid Yeah, in 300 years time you would think the Cerulean Storm would be covering a decent sized portion of the Tyr region mainland by now. |
#30xlorepdarkhelm_dupMar 29, 2004 20:40:30 | Naa. Rajaat cooled off, the Cerulean Storm blew away, and the Sorcerer-Kings reign supreme. Sheesh ;P (Just what we needed, another source that adds even more discrepencies to the Dark Sun timeline...) |
#31AlzriusMar 29, 2004 21:18:41 | The Cerulean Storm is still out over the Silt Sea, and it still sends periodic Tyr Storms across the Tablelands, devestating everything. |
#32nytcrawlrMar 29, 2004 21:25:48 | After 300 years? I seriously doubt that would be the case since it is exapanding....however slowly... |
#33AlzriusMar 29, 2004 21:28:23 | I hadn't heard anything about it expanding that I recall. ::shrugs:: |
#34zombiegleemaxMar 29, 2004 21:40:50 | Well, I wouldn't go nuts just yet... maybe andropinis' early escape and the stalled cerulean storm have something in common... |
#35xlorepdarkhelm_dupMar 29, 2004 21:52:15 | I forget where it is explained that the storm is expanding. But it has to do with the fact that Rajaat's new prison isn't perfect, and he's always getting a little more of him out (and mixed into the storm). But at the same time, Tithian is unwittingly trapping him from completely being released. |
#36nightdruidMar 30, 2004 6:27:38 | Originally posted by NytCrawlr Maybe it hit some sort of limit to its size and ceased to expand. Or maybe it has become cyclical; it expands for a decade or so, then contracts for the next decade. |
#37zombiegleemaxMar 30, 2004 13:28:39 | I guess we can't be pleased in total with what is coming out, but it is new Dark Sun material, so I will take it, just with very large grain of silt. I like Andropinis returning, but I dislike how just about everything in CbtSS was discarded. I especially dislike that templars are just clerics, as templars are one of the best things about Dark Sun IMO. |
#38zombiegleemaxMar 31, 2004 10:58:54 | Actually the New Material is good and bad in several ways; 1)It allows current games to continue on their own personal timelines. 2)Doesnt mess with the Athas.org Write-ups. 3)happens so far ahead of the published timeline that it really has no bearing on a Future Dark Sun(which WOTC is currently mulling over) now the bad. 1) I t gives the hard core DS fans no answers to questions left by the end of TSR support. 2)It doesnt implement the Athas.org write-ups 3)it still leaves fans wondering what happened to XYZ! Now for the comments: ANDROPONIS: Actually in the old DS material Androponis was rumored to be in contact with his templars so it may have been possible for some of his defilers working with natives of the Black to get him released after all the only ones that could possibly prevent that would be the SK's. AZTEZUK: Draj's king could have been helped by someone who knew what lies in the middle of the swamp of the Troll Grave Chasm and he could have become a Sk like that. (the old Dungeon Adventure) Dregoth: Well no mention of the Dray is possible They could have been all wiped out in the war for Raam(their were only 3,338 of them). Dregoth may have decided against transforming 40,000 disloyal raamites into dray would have not have been feasible. They may still exist within his Templarate although a tiny minority. KREEN EMPIRE/INVASION: well We can Infer that the Messenger is what caused the explosion and earthquake(it hit Athas.) It may have devistated the western portion of the Kreen Empire so the kreen have pulled back to recoup losses. |
#39fiendish_dire_weaselMar 31, 2004 23:32:54 | Originally posted by Anorien Ssirinthil WotC is seriously considering doing an actuall book for Dark Sun? Where did you hear this? KREEN EMPIRE/INVASION: well We can Infer that the Messenger is what caused the explosion and earthquake(it hit Athas.) It may have devistated the western portion of the Kreen Empire so the kreen have pulled back to recoup losses. Is this what actually caused the earthquake? I never figured out what caused the earthquake, though I admit to being not nearly as well versed in Athasian lore than others here. |
#40AlzriusMar 31, 2004 23:39:23 | Originally posted by Fiendish Dire Weasel I'd really like to know the answer to this too. It sounds doubtful though. Is this what actually caused the earthquake? I never figured out what caused the earthquake, though I admit to being not nearly as well versed in Athasian lore than others here. There is no canon answer to what caused the earthquake; we don't actually know, and probably never will. That said, the idea that it was due to the Messenger crashing to Athas is a great idea, since it also solves the question of where that comet went to. The only problems I can see with that idea are A) why a comet in a stable path would suddenly veer and crash, and B) why no one would have seen it coming down, since that should have made it plainly visible. |
#41PennarinApr 01, 2004 2:49:04 | Originally posted by Fiendish Dire Weasel It refers to the statement the Editor-in-Chief of Dragon made: «This issue [315] is only a prelude to our next spectacular DRAGON and DUNGEON crossover event. In May, 2004, we're going to release the DARK SUN campaign setting, revised for D&D 3.5!» The next issue of Dragon, 319, will tie-in with what is in Dungeon 110. |
#42OtakkunApr 03, 2004 19:31:52 | I wonder if they could just publish a book with just the timeline of this world. No rules, no prestige classes to balance, nothing, just a plain and simple (an just ONE) timeline. Maybe as a PDF. Edo. |