Would I enjoy Greyhawk?

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

zombiegleemax

Nov 13, 2004 14:44:08
I recently bought the FR setting and realized how hard it would be to work with. There is just too much, many of my players are starting to even read the books so,,,, soon I will be hearing them say that isn't possible or the like. Or, "Why don't we just get Elminster to destroy the orc horde attacking the city?"

So I plan on purchasing the Living Greyhawk Gazetter but i'm worried that I wont have enough ideas or lore. See.....I like a level of lore in-between Greyhawk and FR. I like semi-realism in my games too so I think that I will enjoy it more than FR. I intend on running low-level to mid-level games also so Greyhawk probably fits.

Now for my main question, is their too little to work with in Greyhawk? Can I get other source material outside of the Gazetter?
#2

Yeoman

Nov 13, 2004 15:13:06
Welcome aboard......

Alas there is virtually no current material outside the pages of Dungeon magazine, but downloads of classic material can be found on various sites Eg. Here

Top of my list would be T1-4 Temple of Elemental Evil and the World of Greyhawk boxed set (1983 I think). That should start the creative juices flowing. The campaign detail is light enough to offer plenty of skope for development and hence personal interpretation - what you want goes. No player is going to be able to dictate what happens in your version of the world.

You can also visit Here for a wealth of ideas and material

This is the first time I have tried to post links - hope they work.
I've played Greyhawk campaigns for 20+ years and still love the setting!
#3

Mortepierre

Nov 13, 2004 16:39:18
So I plan on purchasing the Living Greyhawk Gazetter but i'm worried that I wont have enough ideas or lore. See.....I like a level of lore in-between Greyhawk and FR. I like semi-realism in my games too so I think that I will enjoy it more than FR

It really depends on the era you wish to play in.

If it's the EGG period, get the original World of Greyhawk boxed set (available as .pdf).

If it's the Greyhawk Wars that catch your interest, get the From the Ashes boxed set (also available as a .pdf)

If it's the "modern" era, get the Gazetteer.

Personally, I would go with From the Ashes, the Gazetteer, and add a few accessories such as Scarlet Brotherhood, or Slavers (all available as .pdf)

CanonFire is an excellent source of GH lore, though not all of it is "canon".

Out of curiosity, why do you think FR offers more realism than GH? Not to bash on other settings but, frankly, the FR has an overabundance of high levels characters, portals and magic. Compared to that, GH has a grim & gritty feel that is refreshing. Especially when you know that - unlike Mystra's "boy scouts" - the Circle of Eight isn't going to teleport to rescue you whenever you face a crisis.
#4

ivid

Nov 13, 2004 16:45:03
Will you enjoy Greyhawk?

It is not an easy world and a ton of research is needed to adventure in it with sense, so if you seek a *default* world, as a setting for random stuff, I bet you won't have fun with it.

But if you want to use it with all the background that exists, it might be one of the most intriguing campaign grounds you will ever come to see!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
If you want something easy to start with check for the Ivid the Undying book at the wizards download section and see what you can do about it.
Also, the cannonfire! website has many good ideas to start with.
In the Oerth Journals (type that under google) you will find entire fan made adventure of high quality and most of the background information you need to be a DM!

#5

Monteblanco

Nov 13, 2004 17:24:10
Perhaps you will. Greyhawk's history, as told by the Living Greyhawk Gazetteer sounds more believable than the Realms. Additionally, the rarity of ultrahigh level NPCs is beneficial, as the player's deeds will appear to be more relevant and it became easier to imagine low to mid level threats that don't appear to be hollow in face of the NPCs.

Back in the 80s, Greyhawk was designed to be somewhat vague. As such, the DM was free to create the details as he preferred. Although it is currently more detailed than ever, Greyhawk is still pretty much vague in comparison to Forgotten Realms. As such, you will not need to read as much as dozen of books to get a good feeling of the world.

Considering the literature, I suggest you the The Living Greyhawk Gazetteer, and Dungeon Magazine to get the most of the current publications. Some worthy out of print books include The City of Greyhawk Boxed Set and The Scarlet Brotherhood, both for 2nd edition. Also, The Adventure Begins is pretty good, although it is outdated by the LGG and don't offer the flavor of the CoGBS. Finally, go to and download all issues of the Oerth Journal to get excellent fan made material.
#6

zombiegleemax

Nov 13, 2004 17:32:04
Which Era do you guys reccomend I begin play in. First, to help you guys better aid me, my players enjoy a nice balance of hack-slash vs. roleplaying, with a little more in roleplaying.

Which era do you reccomend?
#7

ivid

Nov 13, 2004 17:48:19
If you mean *of the world*, there scarcely exist detailed infos on the older days of Oerth, and if you play there without experience, you miss interesting aspects of the setting, IMO. ;)

If you mean, post- or pre-war, then I recommend you to use pre-war, if you want you play with bought stuff, such as the original Temple of the Elemental Evil etc.
If you want to make up something for yourself, try out something of Ivid the Undying for as a adventure hook. (ItU is short after the Greyhawk Wars.)

#8

Greyson

Nov 13, 2004 22:39:44
Here is the "long" address to Canonfire, the World of Greyhawk's premiere Web site to add to your Internet Favorites:

http://www.canonfire.com/htmlnew/index.php

There is also the RPGA's Living Greyhawk campaign, HERE. You can get involved as a DM and a player in your local region and meta-region. Living Greyhawk got me fired up about the setting. And, you can learn about Greyhawk, past and present, fleece some ideas, and get different approaches to the setting.

Happy gaming.
#9

Yeoman

Nov 14, 2004 1:18:44
Any of the Greyhawk 'Eras' can accomodate a wide range of playing styles. The original boxed set has more of a 'settled' feel to it, with "From The Ashes" involving a more post apocolyptic edge with a continent in turmoil. The Living Greyhawk gazeteer (not sure where this is available now - the boxed sets can be downloaded as previously mentioned) has a mix of both of the above.

Whichever setting you choose should make no real difference, the essence of the Greyhawk campaign is the same IMO.

Happy hunting. :D
#10

omote

Nov 14, 2004 13:40:21
I would suggest starting with the LIVING GREYHAWK GAZETTER, before you get caught up in all of differences in "era." THE LGG is a great books for pure overall setting details. You will know the history, and the major events of nations without the extreme detail of every town like in the current FR. That way you'll be able to expand the World of Greyhawk on your own.

Once you immerse yourself in the LGG tyhen you may find it useful to obtain the older sources of Greyhawk information such as:

FROM THE ASHES
CITY OF GREYAHWK BOX SET
WORLD OF GREYHAWK BOX SET

I also think that the PLAYERS GUIDE TO GREYHAWK and THE ADVENTURE BEGINS are useful with the current LGG.

Final Reccomendations for the best possible start to a Greyhawk Campaign
1.) LIVING GREYHAWK GAZETTER
2.) PLAYERS GUIDE TO GREYHAWK
3.) THE ADVENTURE BEGINS.

...................................Omote
FPQ