Question about Dregoth.

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 8:43:55
In another thread here yesterday I read a comment that Dregoth is unable to continue his dragon metamorphisis to it's final stage because he is undead. Is this just the generally accepted reasoning for why he hasn't done so, or was it laid out somewhere that I missed? I don't see why it would prevent him from meeting the prerequisites, developing or casting the epic spell, or adopting a new template.

I don't know much about undead I guess, so perhaps his condition prevents him from leveling? I don't think that's the case, as NPC undead continue to grow in power all of the time, I can't imagine a spellcaster chosing to become a lich knowing they'd never be able to continue their advancement as a spellcaster... otherwise what's the point of immortality in the first place?

My second question, is if he is unable to complete his change as a result of his being undead, why hasn't he tried to change that? There is at least one example of an epic spell that would restore the undead to life (elven high magic in the forgotten realms setting - obviously up to individuals to decide if it's balanced or not). With his massive level of power, I can't believe he hasn't A) thought of trying to do this or B) failed at it if he did make the attempt.

The answer to these things may just be that he's been working on other stuff, between his research into creating the Dray, his planar traveling, and his aspiring to godhood, plus whatever DA is going to reveal to us, he might not have gotten around to it yet.
#2

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 8:58:54
You have to remember that a lot of the reasons for X and Y and the flavor for Dark Sun come from 2e. It was stated in Dregoth's description in the Revised Dark Sun boxed set (2e) that he could not continue to the last stage because he was undead. It didn't really give any reason, but one assumes it's simply because his undead state prevents it.
Also "epic spells" and the like didn't exist in 2e so that was never a problem. I can't really give you good reasons why Dregoth does or doesn't do anything in 3e as the entire system and structure is different. But in 2e he couldn't advance because of his undead nature and, also in 2e, there was no known way for him to regain his life. So far as I know that fluff has been carried over into 3e but as for "why" in game mechanic terms, I've no idea.
#3

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 9:04:25
I guess I wasn't looking for a pure "cannon" answer, but more of a "what do people think is the reason" discussion.

My personal feeling is what I suggested in the first post, that it's a "so much time, so little to do" (strike that - reverse it) issue, but that depending on what happens in DA, I might have him be researching the possibility of returning himself to life as a campaign arc.
#4

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 9:04:51
Its assumed that being undead hinders the dragon metamorphsis, but is not formally documented.

It has been hinted that Dregoth is working on a way to continue the metamorphsis even in his undead state.

I would think it would be no small task to restore a Dragon King to life. I also think its one of those factors that readers/players need to suspend there disbelief and meta-gaming that he could restore himself to life but that doens't make for a good story.

How interesting is a game world where everyone you kill is brought back to life just because the game mechanics say you can?


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#5

Kamelion

Jun 15, 2004 9:10:06
As suggested, it is most likely a holdover from 2e days. Lich-like undead were barred from advancing in class levels after they became undead in earlier editions of the game. (So Barmoz, in earlier editions becoming a lich was indeed a singularly unattractive prospect for most spellcasters - thankfully that is changed now so we can all become undead to our hearts' content and not worry about a thing, heh heh). Mind you, I think that Ravenloft discarded this rule as Strahd has advanced several times over the course of his career - not sure about this though...
#6

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 9:14:40
Oh, I dunno, I think it would make for a heck of a story to have a sorcerer king searching for specific items or components mentioned in a cryptic piece of arcane lore leftover from the blue age, that gives him the hope that he could actually continue his dragon process.

I'm not talking about using a generic resurrection spell option to do it, I was thinking more along the lines of an epic spell, perhaps beyond even the difficulty and requirements of the dragon metamorphisis itself.
#7

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 9:26:02
Plus, why waste ones efforts and resourses on something as petty as life when you can become Athas' first GOD!!!!!! :devil


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#8

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 9:29:28
I don't recall undead not being able to gain class levels in 2e and to the best of my knowledge most of a lich's time was spent gaining arcane knowledge (ie: wizard levels) which was the entire point of his quest of everlasting "life." Anyway, I'm just getting back into 2e after being away for several years so I might be missing something as well. Of course you didn't have templates that told you word-for-word what happened to a character when he became a lich but in my opinion that was a good thing. ;)
Anyway, what I'd suggest is that an undead creature's body simply isn't able to go through that kind of change (being undead and all).
But if you're looking for something like that in your games (especially as they are 3e) then I say go for it. Come up with whatever epic quest you like and make your PCs a part of it (working for or against). If it will make your games more fun for your group, go with it.
#9

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 10:17:41
The thing I really don't get is that Dregoth is (with Borys gone) quite likely the most powerful individual on (known) Athas. He can almost certainly cast Wish or a psionic-enchantment equivalent. If not, I believe his head templar is pretty high level. You'd think one of them could cast a resurrection spell.
#10

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 10:21:46
Maybe it due to his Draconic nature or something along those lines. It would be like casting raise dead on a God. It just wouldn't/shouldn't work.


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#11

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 10:54:06
Dregoth is currently undead, so wouldn't a res or tru res "kill" him? If so, wouldn't he need two castings of the spell-one to restore him to death and one to restore him to life.

This is putting a lot of faith into the person you have casting the spell, (Mon Adderath?) and puts them in a position to betray you.

That is a pretty big risk to take in someone just to be restored to a mortal form.
#12

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 11:12:50
Eh, then Wish then. Certainly the dude can cast a wish? If not, maybe a psionic enchantment that copies one? It just seems like being undead (for him, at least: freezing him in levels) would be a huge hindrance.

Personally, I've always like the "Undead Dragon King;" it's a cool idea, but it just never rang as logical to me. Something that powerful would not limit its abilities.
#13

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 11:21:25
My guess is that he just doesn't care enough to finish the dragon metamorphsis and is and is to focused on godhood (thats my 3.5
reason anyway).

That or he's worried that if he tried to finish the metamorphsis it would bring to much attention to himself. The SK's killed him once, they could do it again. Even if he was a full dragon could he take on serveral SKs himself?



--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#14

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 11:30:55
Just speculating here, but did the SK's do anything to him after they slew him? Maybe some sort of enchantment to prevent Dregoth from being restored to life?

I admit that his not being able to advance in levels matters more in 3e than in 2e now that epic rules exist. Before it wasn't such a big deal that he could no longer advance, as he only had 1 possible level left to achieve.

As for wish, yeah it could do anything that a resurrection type spell could do, so maybe Dregoth is still undead because he wants to be.
#15

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 11:34:37
They never did state why or how he came to his undead Karsharga (sp?) state. Was it by accident or design?


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#16

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 15, 2004 11:36:52
I took it to be that the dragon metamotrphosis needs the person undergoing it to have actual life energy within themselves (Arcane magic being so very connected to life energy). Any non-living being attempting it, wouldn't have the equation right, and it wouldn't function. Of course, if Dregoth was to research and develop a metamorphosis spell for himself that counteracts this limitation, then.... Bam! New, nastier Dragon of Tyr is born. He's just dealing with the current spell limitations - no reason he couldn't develop a new one, if he had the motivation to do so.
#17

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 11:40:21
I guess it just depends on how important that last level of dragonhood is. I would think that as the final step, it would be a huge asset to him in his pursuit of godhood, but maybe he doesn't feel he needs it or something.

Borys had to be made into a full dragon, they couldn't make him an "almost complete" dragon and still have him be in charge of Rajaat's prison. So there must be some fairly significant power step between an almost and a fully evolved dragon. If Dregoth is the one that developed the process, he has to know what a full dragon is capable of over a partial dragon, I just find it difficult to believe that he's skipping it.

It's like taking a bunch of classes and saying "I don't really need to do those last few credits and get my degree, I'll find a pretty good job with what I have learned already"

The suggestion that the other SK's did something to him when they killed him is a really good one, with clones and contingencies etc, it would be reasonable to think that they went out of their way to prevent him from coming back. They apparently didn't go far enough, but maybe his not-progressing is tied to their actions. Or maybe it is a side effect of the whole dragon process, that a creature must be a "living" being in order to advance.

As far as having his high templar try and do something... the spells from from the elemental vortice, if dregoth "dies" even briefly, before returning to life, is there any guarentee that the templar is going to be able to call upon the source of power needed to manage that second spell brinigng him back to life?
#18

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 11:55:31
Just speculating here, but did the SK's do anything to him after they slew him? Maybe some sort of enchantment to prevent Dregoth from being restored to life?

I tend to agree with this point of view: I don't think Dregoth would willingly stifle his progress so close to the end.
#19

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 12:38:52
dregoth is a kaishrarga. they were barred from gaining any more levels in 2E. The whole thing about them was that the dragon (borys) would turn loyal followers into kaisharga at a certain point so they would gain no more power and maybe be a threat to him. as for dregoth, he prepared himself in the event of his death to become undead as a backup plan, and the result was a state essentially similar to a kaisharga.
#20

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 13:02:25
, he prepared himself in the event of his death to become undead as a backup plan, and the result was a state essentially similar to a kaisharga.

Talk about bad planning on the Dread Kings part. What was wrong with a clone, or contingency spell?

Dregoth must have been sleeping when Rajaat gave that lesson.


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#21

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 13:14:17
Heh. Nice.
#22

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 15, 2004 13:23:35
Originally posted by Sysane
Talk about bad planning on the Dread Kings part. What was wrong with a clone, or contingency spell?

Dregoth must have been sleeping when Rajaat gave that lesson.

Well, everyone's entitled to making a mistake. I think he was more than a little megalomaniacal, and thus, didn't believe that anyone could or would kill him. That his peers would come and do it, he wasn't expecting. Overconfidence seems to be one of hisbiggest failings.
#23

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 13:35:22
I think it makes more scense that the SKs did something to Dregoth after they killed to insure he didn't come back to life (rather than him becoming undead as a back up plan) as previously stated.

Maybe the only way around the spell(s) the SK put on him to keep him from coming back was to bring Dregoth back in undead form? Better to be undead than truly dead.



--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#24

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 13:40:20
Well, everyone's entitled to making a mistake. I think he was more than a little megalomaniacal, and thus, didn't believe that anyone could or would kill him. That his peers would come and do it, he wasn't expecting. Overconfidence seems to be one of hisbiggest failings.

That's an interesting thought, too, and would go a long way to supporting my theory that all the SKs (that came after the "Dregoth incident" anyhow) would have contingency plans in place. So: Tec, Sielba, Kalak would likely have backup plans. Of course, Sielba was done in by Hamanu, so there's a good chance she's so much ash and probably not coming back.
#25

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 15, 2004 13:46:28
Originally posted by Sysane
I think it makes more scense that the SKs did something to Dregoth after they killed to insure he didn't come back to life (rather than him becoming undead as a back up plan) as previously stated.

Maybe the only way around the spell(s) the SK put on him to keep him from coming back was to bring Dregoth back in undead form? Better to be undead than truly dead.

It could be due to the presence of Hamanu - if Hamanu is the Champion designed to kill the other Champions - maybe Dregoth recognized/discovered something about that - and had a contingency to come back to life if he was killed "normally", and then to undeath if killed by Hamanu (as he may not have been able to come back to life if Hamanu killed him) - taking the over-cautious approach.
#26

dawnstealer

Jun 15, 2004 14:12:30
I'd buy that - he seems to be a long-term thinker. This means, of course, that I'll have to make a special template especially for Hamanu.
#27

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 14:21:16
I'm thinking it was more that Ablache-Ra did something to Dregoth than Hammanu.

She seemed to be the ring leader in the whole slaying of Dregoth deal.


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#28

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 15:09:03
As I recall some 2e source material said that Dregoth returned as an undead creature similar to the kaisharga and it was through the work of his head templar. I'll see if I can find the book, passage, etc.
If that's the case then the Sorcerer-Kings probably didn't have anything to do with it and it wasn't in Dregoth's plans either. I tend to think it was just the best the templar could do. As for why he didn't have any backup plan (clone or whatever) I have to agree with Xlorepdarkhelm in that overconfidence seems to be his biggest problem...well, besides being dead.
#29

Sysane

Jun 15, 2004 15:19:58
If that's the case then the Sorcerer-Kings probably didn't have anything to do with it and it wasn't in Dregoth's plans either.

We weren't saying that the SK turned Dregoth into a kaisharga only that they may have cast something on him to insure that he could not be rasied back to life.


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik
#30

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 15, 2004 15:46:48
Originally posted by Sysane
I'm thinking it was more that Ablache-Ra did something to Dregoth than Hammanu.

She seemed to be the ring leader in the whole slaying of Dregoth deal.


--Sysane, The Terror of Urik

Hamanu's unique qualities are alluded to in the Prism Pentad, and in Rise & Fall of a Dragon King. I honestly believe (and use in my campaigns) that Hamanu is....different than the other Sorcerer-Kings. He's been designed - by Rajaat, as his "Final Champion" - not merely to finish off the Trolls for Myron, but also to ensure the completion of Rajaat's work - killing off the rest of the rebirth races, and the other Champions. He's the only known (through multiple sources) replacement Champion (Rise and Fall claims otherwise, but - it's a single source VS several others). As such, while Abalach-Re might have been a ring-leader for it, Hamanu struck the killing blow with his sword Scorcher, and I think that his unique nature absorbed the energy of Dregoth thus making it impossible for him to use a contigency to come back to life. But Dregoth was able to return as an undead, Kaisharga-like creature.
#31

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 15:53:57
The City by the Silt Sea box has the most info about Dregoth, but it doesn't say anything exact about the process. Dregoth was a level 29 dragon, then the SKs lead by Abalach-Re came and killed him as they were afraid having one more crazy dragon on rampage besides Borys. They used spells and psionics and Hamanu used a black sword to cut him down. Dregoth fall under the attack as it took him by surprise. He was killed and the SKs left the scene. The city was ruined, the people who was not syphoned off of life run away. Then Mon Addreath found the refugees and led them to New Guistenal where Dregoth waited for them. As the book wrote: he was dead but only for a time.

As Dregoth's undead state was not a planned process but most possibly a contingency emergency measure it can be more difficult or impossible for him to continue the metamorphosis. But I think he doesn't bother with it. If he could be a god he gains much more than he could with this last level a dragonship.
#32

elonarc

Jun 15, 2004 16:02:03
Dregoth was a level 29 dragon, then the SKs lead by Abalach-Re came and killed him

In another thread some months ago there was already an discussion about the difference of "Abalach-Re, the paranoid man eater" as everyone knows her and "Abalach-Re, the initiator of the killing plot against the most powerful being of Athas".
I really liked the idea that Abalach-Re and Dregoth might have been lovers ages ago and the split of the two made her snap and become what she is today.
It would be an explanation why she seems so "weak" yet still is a sorcerer queen and adds tremendously to the dept of the character.
#33

zombiegleemax

Jun 15, 2004 23:33:35
Originally posted by Elonarc
In another thread some months ago there was already an discussion about the difference of "Abalach-Re, the paranoid man eater" as everyone knows her and "Abalach-Re, the initiator of the killing plot against the most powerful being of Athas".
I really liked the idea that Abalach-Re and Dregoth might have been lovers ages ago and the split of the two made her snap and become what she is today.
It would be an explanation why she seems so "weak" yet still is a sorcerer queen and adds tremendously to the dept of the character.

I like that explanation as well, it makes sense why Dregoth would harbor such hatred for her. Perhaps while sharing a romantic dalliance he showed her his "true" form and revealed some of his plans. And so Abalach-Re organized the assault to take him out, but the guilt and loneliness eventually caused her mental gears to start slipping. Perhaps she and Sielba were also "friends" of a sort, and Sielba's death left her with no sorcerer-king allies anymore.

As far as Dregoth's metamorphic state, it makes sense to me that he can no longer advance. From a story point of view, a full dragon, a mockery of life itself, must be living. Mechanics-wise, I don't think sorcerer kings in 3.5 should be a class, instead they're stages of a "dragon" monster template that are innately able to manifest powers and cast spells without class levels. In Dregoth's case, I'd add that while he can cast arcane spells, doing so hurts him, causing damage to him from the effort of channeling life force through his undead frame. (Really tichy damage amounts, like 1d4 per spell level.)

Of course, it's all a moot point, because Dregoth doesn't care to advance any further as a dragon anyway. What he wants is true godhood. It's interesting that both he and Borys use undead in the same fashion, a useful tool but nothing more. Most of Dungeon #110's background materials were okay, some inconsistencies here and there, but some good ideas scattered about. But one glaring problem is Dregoth as sorcerer-king of Raam. City by the Silt Sea makes it pretty clear that Dregoth intended to slaughter the entire city to empower his apotheosis (fat chance of that!), and he really shows little inclination towards death. And also, what happened to the Dray?

Here's an idea of my own as to why, if you're using Dungeon #110 for your campaigns, the Dray aren't present: When Dregoth lead his army to the surface, he found out that the 2nd generation Dray couldn't bear the light of Athas's red sun, and died almost immediately. So Dregoth retreated to brood for awhile, and decided that maybe "undead" was the true path to perfect evolution... like cockroaches, they can survive anywhere, they don't need food, drink, or air to live, and anyone can make the transition to the state. So he returned to Raam, leaving his "imperfect" creations of Dray to their own fate, and began his "city of creation".

Adamantyr
#34

zombiegleemax

Jun 16, 2004 7:17:19
Even during their tenure as chief minions of the First Sorcerer, the sorcerer-kings were power-hungry bastards. Hell, most of them didn't even truly believe in Rajaat's "holy" crusade to restore the Blue Age by exterminating the Rebirth races; they merely saw an unequalled opportunity for power, and took it, to hell with all the Rebirth races!

With this in mind, most of the former Champions had to have explored the possibility of undeath as a route to ever-greater mystic and psionic might. I believe the kaisharga process was known even during the Time of Magic (pre-Cleansing Wars), and thus was ignored by the Champions as a source of power.

Thus, when 7 of the remaining Champions ambushed Dregoth, they worked like mad to eliminate any possibility of the mad dragon-king ever coming back...but they failed to notice the possibility of him returning as a kaisharga. As far as Abalach-Re and the others were concerned, Dregoth would be much more manageable in the unlikely event he would be desperate enough to come back as a kaisharga. Furthermore, if he did come back as a kaisharga, they could use the temptation of restoring him to true life as a method of blackmail and control....

--in their minds, it was a reasonable chance to undertake NB
#35

zombiegleemax

Jun 16, 2004 7:21:08
As for Abalach-Re, I've always played her thusly: She is an incredible general and warlord, far more cunning and capable in the battlefield than even the likes of Hamanu. She'd have to be, to have managed to wipe out every single Athasian orc. It's just that she's a crappy monarch, not really suited for the position of queen. Just because you're good on the battlefield does not automatically guarantee you'll be equally good in the throne room.

--sometimes the most sterling of generals makes the worst of rulers NB
#36

jaanos

Jun 16, 2004 7:30:04
Although multiple sources say that Dregoth was a 29th level dragon when he died... this little gem emerges:

Page 88, in chapter 6, Dregoth and the Dray, in the City by the Silt Sea:

"In life, Dregoth was a 27th-level dragon, on the verge of achieving the final stage of metamorphis"

OK - that little gem raises all sorts of issues.

#1 - is the reference to the final stage a mistake, a typo, or maybe a vauge reference to the low-mid-high distinctions in the 10-level transformation process?

If you take the final train of thought, then Dregoth HAS advanced since his death.... which flies in the face of everything else, i know, but hey, if you are part of the 'why should undeath prevent advancement' school, there's a potential answer: it doesn't and didn't.

Just when you thought cannon was safe, that comes along.....

#37

zombiegleemax

Jun 16, 2004 8:52:52
Originally posted by Jaanos
Although multiple sources say that Dregoth was a 29th level dragon when he died... this little gem emerges:

Page 88, in chapter 6, Dregoth and the Dray, in the City by the Silt Sea:

"In life, Dregoth was a 27th-level dragon, on the verge of achieving the final stage of metamorphis"

I wouldn't call that a gem so much as a typo. Since everything else says 29th, I would ignore that particular figure.

City by the Silt Sea shows signs of having been edited in a rather chopped fashion. The chapter on Dregoth and the Dray has his biography from his monstrous compendium entry nearly word-for-word repeated, and the same elements of information are restated several times throughout the whole book. The product on a whole is superb, mind you, considering it was the final years of TSR.

Adamantyr
#38

nytcrawlr

Jun 16, 2004 17:51:22
Mwuahahaha!

So hard to keep back what I know of DA in regards to this discussion.

Nah, nevermind, I am actually enjoying the torture.

#39

zombiegleemax

Jun 16, 2004 18:14:20
Originally posted by NytCrawlr
Mwuahahaha!

So hard to keep back what I know of DA in regards to this discussion.

Nah, nevermind, I am actually enjoying the torture.


That's okay, I'm sure it will be released. About the same time that Hamanu decides to go hippie and start a rock band. :D

Adamantyr
#40

nytcrawlr

Jun 16, 2004 18:17:01
Originally posted by Adamantyr
That's okay, I'm sure it will be released. About the same time that Hamanu decides to go hippie and start a rock band. :D

Well, I know there are people on an Epic bureau now, so maybe there's hope it will be out sometime later next year.

Course I could still be dreaming too, hehe.
#41

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 16, 2004 21:43:30
Originally posted by NytCrawlr
Well, I know there are people on an Epic bureau now, so maybe there's hope it will be out sometime later next year.

Course I could still be dreaming too, hehe.

I'll try to light a fire under some people. Now.... where's that industrial blow torch at, and just point me in the direction of the oracle's blue shrine. Gotta go start my first fire...
#42

jaanos

Jun 17, 2004 5:44:38
of course it's a typo, but it still makes for an interesting thought - that dregoth HAS progressed since his death.

Originally posted by Adamantyr
I wouldn't call that a gem so much as a typo. Since everything else says 29th, I would ignore that particular figure.

City by the Silt Sea shows signs of having been edited in a rather chopped fashion. The chapter on Dregoth and the Dray has his biography from his monstrous compendium entry nearly word-for-word repeated, and the same elements of information are restated several times throughout the whole book. The product on a whole is superb, mind you, considering it was the final years of TSR.

Adamantyr

#43

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jun 17, 2004 6:52:45
Originally posted by Jaanos
of course it's a typo, but it still makes for an interesting thought - that dregoth HAS progressed since his death.

I'd say that while he's progressed - it hasn't been as a Dragon. he's been busy, but the advantage of the 3/3.5e multiclass rules is - he's not trapped to specifically develop as a Dragon. And honestly, I believe he's had other things preoccupying his time.
#44

zombiegleemax

Jun 30, 2004 23:37:58
About his aparent inability to come back to life:

The Hamanu presence theory holds some water. Besides which god would submit to the magic of his worshippers?

Even is his templar can ressurect him (not that he can...) would Dregoth allow it? He returned form the dead by "sheer force of will" to guide his people to the conquest of the world. That seems pretty godlike to me.

About the advancing part:

Really in 2e undead could not advance (as far as I remember). Ravenloft used some rules to circunvent that, but in generalundeath meant a stop in evolution.

In 3e he could be able advance to full dragonhood, BUT if we was cursed in someway, like Azalin (from Ravenloft) that can't learn a new spell or advance in levels?

It would make him frustrated two times: once for his inability to achieve full dragonhood and twice for not be able to become a true god (as I don't know DA end, I can't really back this up except for previous material).
#45

dracochapel

Jul 01, 2004 1:04:25
The way i DM in Dark Sun is that there are NO raise dead or resurrect spells of any sort, and no limited wishes/wish - Dark Sun is harsh, if you die - thats it, welcome to the grey.
So for me that cuts out Dregoth been raised up again (and if hes dead how does the high templar get the magic power to cast raise dead or resurrect?)

I think Dregoth came back as an undead the same way many of the other athasian undead return to life - he had unfinished business, and it had nothing to do with contingencies or anything similar.

Since he is undead he can no longer advance as a dragon, his body is effectively in stasis, he cant go back to been alive and he cant go forward to been a full dragon.

Also i dont think hes been advancing in any other classes, i dont think any of the advanced beings can level in other classes once they are progressing in their chosen dragon/avangion path. I imagine it would be like paladins/monks multiclassing and been unable to go back - and dregoth REALLY wants to be a full dragon.(or wanted)
#46

zombiegleemax

Jul 01, 2004 5:13:45
I think Dregoth came back as an undead the same way many of the other athasian undead return to life - he had unfinished business, and it had nothing to do with contingencies or anything similar.

Actually, Dregoth was raised as an undead by his lifelong friend Mon Adderath.
#47

nytcrawlr

Jul 01, 2004 14:59:51
Originally posted by DracoChapel
Since he is undead he can no longer advance as a dragon, ..., ... and he cant go forward to been a full dragon.

Too bad there is documentation proving you are wrong on that, heh.
#48

Sysane

Jul 01, 2004 15:32:43
Too bad there is documentation proving you are wrong on that, heh.

Cut the man some slack.

He's not completly wrong. There is documentation stating he couldn't advance in the original CBtSS box set as well.
#49

nytcrawlr

Jul 01, 2004 15:51:09
Originally posted by Sysane
Cut the man some slack.

He's not completly wrong. There is documentation stating he couldn't advance in the original CBtSS box set as well.

Well, when there is new documentation stating otherwise he is, heh.

Wasn't trying to be harsh, just pointing out he's wrong.
#50

Sysane

Jul 01, 2004 17:43:55
Well, when there is new documentation stating otherwise he is, heh.

I take it you mean in DA?
#51

nytcrawlr

Jul 01, 2004 17:58:28
Originally posted by Sysane
I take it you mean in DA?

You would be correct.

A historical moment happens in that adventure and kills that rule completely, despite the fact that 3e killed it already, but that's a mechanic vs. flavor argument.
#52

Sysane

Jul 01, 2004 18:26:31
You would be correct.

Well he's not entirely wrong then. Publicly published and know by the masses takes precedence over privately published and known by the few material. ((hint, hint))
#53

nytcrawlr

Jul 01, 2004 18:47:29
Originally posted by Sysane
Well he's not entirely wrong then. Publicly published and know by the masses takes precedence over privately published and known by the few material. ((hint, hint))

Uh, wow, ok.

Excuse me for not entertaining such bad logic.
#54

dracochapel

Jul 01, 2004 19:58:03
Good to know he makes it then. I was wondering about the Ascending bit - whether it was physical (him returning to the surface) or represented him returning to life/becoming a full dragon.

I dont think they'll ever release Dregoth Ascending, its too good as a trump card -
Too bad there is documentation proving you are wrong on that, heh.

:D Works for every argument
#55

nytcrawlr

Jul 01, 2004 20:24:37
Originally posted by DracoChapel
Good to know he makes it then. I was wondering about the Ascending bit - whether it was physical (him returning to the surface) or represented him returning to life/becoming a full dragon.

Oh, it's definately physical, and he remains undead.

I dont think they'll ever release Dregoth Ascending, its too good as a trump card

Don't lose hope.

Like I said, we're on the right track, we at least have an Epic bureau up and running.
#56

Sysane

Jul 01, 2004 20:56:45
Excuse me for not entertaining such bad logic.

Bro,

lighten up it was a joke.

And lose the condescending attitude.....
#57

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jul 02, 2004 2:41:28
Originally posted by DracoChapel
I dont think they'll ever release Dregoth Ascending, its too good as a trump card

Well, the Epic Bureau is definitely working on meshing out some Epic Rules. Which are rather important, since Dregoth Ascending is well... very Epic. And what does Athas.org have to gain by witholding DA from the public? Nothing other than a bunch of tee'd off fans. It's my impression that DA was a) incomplete, and b) needs some serious work to be updated to 3.5e rules - which if I remember correctly, is something that's part of the deal for releasing it that Wizards of the Coast requires.

Now - I can't say one way or another on what the Epic Bureau has planned, but it will be something that's simplistic and yet not heavily watered down. The people at Athas.org are fans of the campaign setting, and to date, have released rules that retain the flavor of the setting.
#58

zombiegleemax

Jul 02, 2004 9:09:17
Originally posted by xlorepdarkhelm
Well, the Epic Bureau is definitely working on meshing out some Epic Rules. Which are rather important, since Dregoth Ascending is well... very Epic. And what does Athas.org have to gain by witholding DA from the public? Nothing other than a bunch of tee'd off fans. It's my impression that DA was a) incomplete, and b) needs some serious work to be updated to 3.5e rules - which if I remember correctly, is something that's part of the deal for releasing it that Wizards of the Coast requires.

Now - I can't say one way or another on what the Epic Bureau has planned, but it will be something that's simplistic and yet not heavily watered down. The people at Athas.org are fans of the campaign setting, and to date, have released rules that retain the flavor of the setting.

Having seen Dregoth Ascending I can say that it was *complete* as it could be as any first draft of a product was back then. It was not edited, nor playtested; however, the plot was there as was the overall "feel" of what the adventure was supposed to be, and everything else needed to play a 2E adventure. As I posted on another thread, it could be released as 2E very easily, but would likely require work on a DM's part to integrate it into a 2E campaign given the fact that 8-9 years have passed since the last DS adventure was released. Really, a 2E editing pass and typesetting would do the trick. The only thing missing would be maps and art; but since most people today prefer 3E+ is probably the reason we have not seen it.

As for your comment on "serious" work to be updated to 3.5, that could be said for anything written 8 or more years ago, in 2E, with some of the old Player's Option (I think) thrown in. The work was simply written for a different genre. Not to start a debate, but I think it's unfair to discount the product on those terms simply because Athas.org has not done it yet. Remember too that I'm sure everyone involved with Athas.org have 'real' lives and do not have 15 hours a day to devote to stuff like this. I think they've done a great job considering, but I too would like to see DA done in 3E or 3.5E. In the end I think DA is a vicitm of circumstance more than anything else.

If anything blast WoTC for allowing this campaign to langish in limbo for some many years when it used to be second fiddle to FR years ago. They refuse to do it themselves (nothing against Eberron, but I would have loved to see DS instead), ask enormous fees for liscensing in an industry that quite frankly sucks right now, and insisting on printing the campaign book themselves which is where the money in any setting really is. Ravenloft was a gift to SS that would never be repeated, and Dragonlance was practically given to Margaret because of who she is --- and that leaves DS in a pile of dung. I've always hoped that someone in Renton would wake up and smell the coffee someday, but I'm more and more convinced that it will never happen.

AnOldGamer
#59

zombiegleemax

Jul 02, 2004 10:24:00
Originally posted by AnOldGamer
I've always hoped that someone in Renton would wake up and smell the coffee someday, but I'm more and more convinced that it will never happen.

Over on the Mystara boards, most of the posters are expressing relief to have been passed over by Paizo and WotC. They don't even mind that the "Isle of Dread" remake will be set in GreyHawk instead, it just helps distance themselves from "official support".

I always look forward to new material, although my present campaign is set in the original timeline era, so I don't even have to worry about Dregoth yet.

The only thing that concerns me is the thought of an "epic-only" campaign setting. The epic rules are far from polished, especially where epic-level spells and powers are concerned. And the original Dark Sun adventures never required 21+ level characters, they found ways around the problem and even had the players scrapping with a sorcerer-king once in awhile, without epic levels.

Granted, the original adventures had their inconsistencies with power levels. Dune Trader has ridiculously high levels for the NPC's listed; I'd suggest anyone converting them reduce their level count by 1/3 to 1/2. Dragon's Crown has multiple 21+ level psionisists that fight the players. The big change here, though, is in 3.5 characters are much stronger at higher levels than they were previously. A 20th level psion in 3.5 is far more powerful than a 20th level psionisist in 2e.

Dark Sun has always been about the underdogs. Fighting to survive, living in the moment. Epic-level games are Dragonball Z style fights where spellcasters run everything. Ask yourself which suits the "flavor" of the setting more.

Adamantyr
#60

zombiegleemax

Jul 02, 2004 14:49:35
Originally posted by AnOldGamer
If anything blast WoTC for allowing this campaign to langish in limbo for some many years when it used to be second fiddle to FR years ago. They refuse to do it themselves (nothing against Eberron, but I would have loved to see DS instead)...

That was a step I never understand: why WotC started searching for new game worlds when there were excellent old ones? (Like DS, Birthright, etc.) Did they have fear that comparing the 2e and the 3e DS would be a cause for dissatisfaction? Or are there other (possibly licensing or other legal) issues in the background we are not aware of? No, in this case they couldn't made the athas.org version an official one... But they could give DS to the Sword and Sorcery guys as they did with Ravenloft. Well... Just loud thinking...
#61

zombiegleemax

Jul 02, 2004 14:53:53
Originally posted by Adamantyr
Over on the Mystara boards, most of the posters are expressing relief to have been passed over by Paizo and WotC.

Ohh, nobody can avoid Fate... Sooner or later you will find the title on the cover of the latest Dragon magazine: "Mystara renewed! New rules, new goodies! Explore the classic AD&D world again!"

You can run but you can't hiiiiiiiiiiiide...

(Poor fellows on the Mystara boards, I honestly wish you all the bests, and I cross my fingers that those day will never come...)
#62

darkbard3

Jul 06, 2004 12:45:36
Personally, I hope that WoTC stays away from a DS3.x conversion. I've read thru the material from both Dragon and Dungeon magazines, and although I snagged a few gems from both sources for campaign ideas and rules variants, my DS game is 98% Athas.org source material. To me, flavor is everything, and it is the closest to 2e DS flavor as one can get. As for DA, well, I'm just hoping I can see it out before I get my players up to that point. I have a storyline leading up to front-row seats to Borys' death, then off to play with Dregoth. I'd prefer running DA to a CbySS conversion.
#63

dracochapel

Jul 08, 2004 2:10:13
So im guessing Dregoth was TSR's Borys Mark 2.
I mean after killing off the guy whos keeping rajaat imprisoned they need someone to take over that job.
And look whos in the corner - a 29th level dragon, mysteriously 7 levels higher than the average SK, and just itching to make it all the way.

I wonder how many people he has to eat to make it, and what special things he has to do to account for his undead state (since i cant imagine that it has NO influence on becoming a full dragon).

And if he makes any new SK's.....
#64

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jul 08, 2004 4:11:28
Originally posted by DracoChapel
So im guessing Dregoth was TSR's Borys Mark 2.
I mean after killing off the guy whos keeping rajaat imprisoned they need someone to take over that job.
And look whos in the corner - a 29th level dragon, mysteriously 7 levels higher than the average SK, and just itching to make it all the way.

I wonder how many people he has to eat to make it, and what special things he has to do to account for his undead state (since i cant imagine that it has NO influence on becoming a full dragon).

And if he makes any new SK's.....

Not quite, more like TSR's Rajaat Mark II. Dregoth really doesn't care about the other Champions, or imprisoning Rajaat much. Well, correction, he'd like all the other Champions probably dead for what they did to him.

My personal take on this is - Dregoth developed the Dragon metamorphosis spells when he was still hunting Giants - which is why he stayed in Giustenal for as long as he did. He developed it, and cast it on himself. Rajaat discovered it later and restructured it for his Champion Mark II, a.k.a. Hamanu. Dregoth then even later shows the Dragon metamorphosis process to Borys. Borys then uses the Dark Lens to initiate the Dragon process in the other Sorcerer-Kings (except for Dregoth, who already had begun the process, and Hamanu, who was another kind of Dragon). He needed the other Sorcerer-Kings to become dragons, so that they had more power to provide for him to advance to the final stage. Dregoth may have even suggested Borys undergoes this rather than Dregoth himself, who was using the Dwarf Butcher as a guinea pig, to see the effects of accelerated development has on the individual, and to have some empirical evidence of what happens, so that he could work on counteracting it. Borys goes mad, and Dregoth spends time working on how to overcome the madness himself. Just before he achieves the final stage, his "brothers" and "sisters" kindly murder him. Hamanu, the "freak" delivers the killing blow, disabling any contingency plan Dregoth had (Hamanu's unique nature left an unknown factor in Dregoth's plans). his long-time friend Mon Addaloth (sp?) resurrects him as a Kaisharga-like creature.

The problem he now has is - the final spell only works if the dragon it is being cast upon is living. But - Dregoth found a portal. The only known portal to the Outer Planes.... So, rather than worrying about full Dragonhood, instad the Outer Planes have to worry about a loose undead Athasian Dragon wandering around, learning what he can about the Outer Planes - something even Rajaat could not accomplish.

Heck, I've even run a couple non-Dark Sun campaigns where the group gets some missions/quests from Dregoth in disguise. There was one group which a cleric decided that casting "detect evil" was a good thing, to ensure the honesty of the individual giving them their quest. About 1 1/2 combat rounds later, everyone was making new characters.
#65

zombiegleemax

Jul 08, 2004 5:28:26
xlorep(excuse my condensation of your name),
how do you find players that keep playing after you have their characters smoked for casting detect evil or no matter what they do the adventure outcome is the same?
#66

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jul 08, 2004 11:31:02
It's simple, I leave a few clues that it is a bad idea, and then the person who does that generally intentionally does the stupid thing. He gets laughed at, and the group keeps going. It's not like I just, out of the blue, kill their characters without them having at least some idea that it's generally a bad thing. And - quite honestly, my players like my games. They always tell me that they have a lot of fun with them. I guess it's all in the presentation.

Oh, and that's not a bad condensation. I needed to spell out "Xlorep DarkHelm" when I signed up, but had been used to places where spaces were not accepted, so I simply wrote it all out in one long word instead. I found out afterwards that I could have had capitalization and the space in it. Oh well, lessons learned and stuff.
#67

zombiegleemax

Jul 08, 2004 12:47:19
sorry, after i looked at that again this morning i realized that question wasn't worded very well. glad you didn't take offense.
#68

zombiegleemax

Jul 08, 2004 17:36:59
Originally posted by xlorepdarkhelm
The problem he now has is - the final spell only works if the dragon it is being cast upon is living. But - Dregoth found a portal. The only known portal to the Outer Planes.... So, rather than worrying about full Dragonhood, instad the Outer Planes have to worry about a loose undead Athasian Dragon wandering around, learning what he can about the Outer Planes - something even Rajaat could not accomplish.

I wouldn't say that Rajaat could not accomplish it, I find it difficult to believe that any magical artifact in existence in the world where he discovered magic would be beyond his capacity to create or duplicate the effects of. I would instead say that Rajaat's pursuit of returning Athas to the blue age did not lead him down that path of activity.

Also I really like your take on the history of the dragon metamorphisis process, who developed it, who modified it, what activities surrounded the transformation of all of the champions into dragons. As part of the epic bureau at athas.org, can we assume that your views, specifically a different dragon process for hamanu, your 4 stage dragon metamorphisis process, and the like will be heavily incorporated?
#69

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Jul 09, 2004 13:06:39
Originally posted by Barmoz
I wouldn't say that Rajaat could not accomplish it, I find it difficult to believe that any magical artifact in existence in the world where he discovered magic would be beyond his capacity to create or duplicate the effects of. I would instead say that Rajaat's pursuit of returning Athas to the blue age did not lead him down that path of activity.

Actually, there is some canon material (hopefully, this will be released soon) that out and out states that Rajaat was incapable of getting to the outer planes. He had devoted many of his resources to accomplish it, and never did.

Also I really like your take on the history of the dragon metamorphisis process, who developed it, who modified it, what activities surrounded the transformation of all of the champions into dragons. As part of the epic bureau at athas.org, can we assume that your views, specifically a different dragon process for hamanu, your 4 stage dragon metamorphisis process, and the like will be heavily incorporated?

Well, don't assume anything, I say. While I'd like to see my system taken in there, I can't promise anything. I also can't really say what we're working on - but it's definitely stepping along in the right direction, I believe. And - it's not stagnating - there's all kinds of activity in the Epic Bureau.