Release Dark Sun for 3.5 D&D: the petition is alive

Post/Author/DateTimePost
#1

jesterjeff

Dec 07, 2004 19:53:24
Ladies and Gentlemen, boys and girls of all ages, I give you what you want and what we deserve. Please read this and sign were provided. If you wish to take it to the real world for signatures, please go only to rpg groups game stores, and comic shops. When you recieve as many as you dsire, please email me for my address. I will collect all petitions and signatures and deliver them to the appropriate individuals.This is our chance to show our support of this great setting. Good luck to us all.

Jeff Lawson

http://www.petitiononline.com/darksun3/petition.html
#2

zombiegleemax

Dec 07, 2004 20:38:21
#3

zombiegleemax

Dec 08, 2004 0:31:46
#4

zombiegleemax

Dec 08, 2004 5:55:37
I've signed it!
#5

brun01

Dec 08, 2004 7:33:11
I'm signature number 21. That has always been my lucky number! :D
#6

jesterjeff

Dec 08, 2004 9:43:40
we're taking it slow and steady folks but hopefully we'll get a decent number, come on We had around 70 views, at least half of ya'll should be jumping over to sign.
#7

nytcrawlr

Dec 08, 2004 13:15:24
Up to 34 so far?

Not too bad, needs some improvement though if you want this to ever succeed.



I think I was #4 or something when I signed it.
#8

nytcrawlr

Dec 08, 2004 13:42:00
Damn boards....
#9

zombiegleemax

Dec 08, 2004 19:15:51
#10

Sysane

Dec 08, 2004 19:21:01
Could this get stickied some how?
#11

jesterjeff

Dec 08, 2004 19:47:42
we can only hope so, the question is who do we ask to do so?

http://www.petitiononline.com/darksun3/petition.html
sign up folks we need all the support we can get
#12

zombiegleemax

Dec 08, 2004 19:47:56
We don't know who to ask.
#13

jaanos

Dec 08, 2004 20:06:54
done. bring it on.
#14

nytcrawlr

Dec 08, 2004 20:55:13
Ask Flip or Jon to sticky it for you.
#15

zombiegleemax

Dec 08, 2004 21:07:07
Jon says neither Flip nor himself have the capacity to do so.
:raincloud
#16

jihun-nish

Dec 08, 2004 21:39:06
Just glad to be able to participate in this petition occasion. (51)
#17

nytcrawlr

Dec 08, 2004 22:14:03
Jon says neither Flip nor himself have the capacity to do so.
:raincloud

Flip has sticked things before, what happen to that special power?
#18

zombiegleemax

Dec 09, 2004 0:06:44
I and my players, whom I would force to buy minimum 4 athas.org PHB's and at least 2 extra copies of the rewritten wanderer's journal for party use (not counting my own copies), have signed.

Long live the revolution!

The wonderful thing about this, from WoTC standpoint, is that Dark Sun is so unique that a normal phb just can't cut it. Most games will require multiple copies of the athas.org material to run effectively and extra copies of the setting material for player use is almost as crucial.

I'd like to see a "Dark Sun Gazeteer" much like the Greyhawk Gazeteer. My greyhawk group has 4 copies of that world's book floating around the table at any one time (6 players). With a setting as singular as Dark Sun it is almost a foregone conclusion that the same setup would appear.
#19

zombiegleemax

Dec 09, 2004 11:50:15
:P
#20

jesterjeff

Dec 09, 2004 11:56:38
Come on Cousin
Tell your friends
We've a Petition
To Raise the 'Sun' again

Hurry Love
no time to waste
To spill Thri-Kreen blood
is a thrill to taste

Psions and Rangers
running wild in the heat
A life filled with Dangers
Dark Sun can't be beat.

http://www.petitiononline.com/darksun3/petition.html
#21

zombiegleemax

Dec 09, 2004 13:15:14
I'm #63, even if I like 69 better... But this is a totally different story... :D
#22

nytcrawlr

Dec 09, 2004 13:36:38
I'm #63, even if I like 69 better... But this is a totally different story... :D

:heehee



My craziness must be rubbing off on people, mwuahahahaha!
#23

jon_oracle_of_athas

Dec 09, 2004 18:11:45
Flip has sticked things before, what happen to that special power?

Flip got exposed to Kryptonite.
#24

Grummore

Dec 09, 2004 18:20:44
Flip got exposed to Kryptonite.

What do you mean?? He lost is power from wotc? Why?
#25

zombiegleemax

Dec 09, 2004 20:40:21
this should be in athas.org by now... how about an emergency update?
#26

zombiegleemax

Dec 10, 2004 5:38:40
We've already posted on our site!!
And spreaded it over some big brazilian RPG mailing-lists.

So, come on, everyone:
-All those who breathe should vote.
-All those who don't should vote too. :pile:
#27

brun01

Dec 10, 2004 6:06:45
ONE HUNDRED SIGNATURES!!!!

come on, people, we can do much better than that!

Start the already!
#28

jesterjeff

Dec 10, 2004 10:03:19
116* Insert Villainous Laughter*

Come on folks, all you who've read this page, and there are many. please make a statement if you agree.
#29

jon_oracle_of_athas

Dec 10, 2004 11:34:52
Petition link is up at athas.org.
#30

xlorepdarkhelm_dup

Dec 10, 2004 12:07:44
I'll sign, but in my experience, online petitions really accomplish nothing.
#31

zombiegleemax

Dec 10, 2004 12:58:49
132 oh yeah! But.......still need..........more signatures.
#32

Sysane

Dec 10, 2004 13:08:01
We could always picket or have a sit-in
#33

jesterjeff

Dec 10, 2004 14:08:37
will there be compy chairs? I'm always for a sit in if I can have the compy chair. And as we sit in and protest, someone could run a campaign.
#34

zombiegleemax

Dec 10, 2004 18:15:48

:fight!: :fight!:
#35

zombiegleemax

Dec 10, 2004 19:45:57
Before I do something wrong I will ask, yeah I learned from my faults :D .

I have some of comilitones who would sign this petition when I would ask them, but they aren't yet no Dark Sun fans, so do you need their voices?
#36

jesterjeff

Dec 10, 2004 20:15:57
If we wanted raw numbers, send them. but this is ment to be a unified cry to Wizards to give us what we want.

Why wouldn't they be fans, not gamers or more fond of standard tolkienesque fantasy worlds.
#37

zombiegleemax

Dec 10, 2004 20:57:44

:fight!: :fight!:
#38

zombiegleemax

Dec 11, 2004 1:28:06

:angelhide
#39

gilliard_derosan

Dec 11, 2004 10:05:49
#190 baby!! But considering that the most fun I have ever had in a D&D game was while playing Engus, the Half Giant Fighter, protector of the oppressed, Templar of Borys (Long story), Dregtoh Slayer (and owner of all his nifty toys. . . at least until he finds a way to come back for them)

I have always loved Dark Sun. I hated the Realms, I hated old 2nd AD&D, until my buddy said "Hey, I got this cool new desert campaign for D&D, we gotta try it" The rest is history
#40

jesterjeff

Dec 11, 2004 12:43:56
well, we're at 199, keep em coming.
#41

zombiegleemax

Dec 11, 2004 21:47:44
222 and going on... c'mon people! We need 10000 at least!!!
#42

zombiegleemax

Dec 11, 2004 23:12:12
#225.
#43

jesterjeff

Dec 12, 2004 9:34:53
#240 right now nd still growing, come on folks keep it up. We're getting alot more people viewing this page than posting, so come on folks if ya read this support our cause and haven't signed. Sign!

http://www.petitiononline.com/darksun3/petition.html
#44

zombiegleemax

Dec 12, 2004 17:34:42
#45

Oninotaki

Dec 12, 2004 23:46:11
# 268! I really hope this works!
#46

nytcrawlr

Dec 13, 2004 14:54:41
The problem with the view totals compared to number of people that have signed is going to be skewed anyways, only because I think for everytime anyone views the thread it is counted.
#47

zombiegleemax

Dec 14, 2004 4:48:38
Been working way too much lately, rather seems I've missed alot. A whole lot. I'll be more than happy to sign, so long as the clause is that WOTC utilized the Athas.org material in as much capacity as they can (I would highly doubt they would simply toss the money into a book that could be gleaned off the net for free) AND if they at least retain the members of Athas.org in some way, although I don't see WOTC hiring on a group of technically mostly unpublished writers since they don't view internet publications as valid except in the most extreme cases.

Still, I can't see WOTC publishing a book that I'd be happy with in the long run, unless of course they took the route that they did with Dragonlance where SS did all the work, and WOTC gets all the credit for the hardcover, since the Athas.org team has already done most of the work.

(edit) Which makes me a much belated signer #324.
#48

mrfilthyike

Dec 14, 2004 8:11:17
Come on Cousin
Tell your friends
We've a Petition
To Raise the 'Sun' again

Hurry Love
no time to waste
To spill Thri-Kreen blood
is a thrill to taste

Psions and Rangers
running wild in the heat
A life filled with Dangers
Dark Sun can't be beat.

http://www.petitiononline.com/darksun3/petition.html

After that terrible poem, how could I not sign just to make him stop?!

;)

Just Kidding. I signed, number 331 I think.
#49

jesterjeff

Dec 14, 2004 11:04:11
ouch a literary critic.

it's been a while since i did some decent poetry. although I am in that limerick thread.
#50

Torack

Dec 14, 2004 12:54:36
Not meaning to break the fun anyone is having with all this, but wouldn't it be easier to simply buy the rights to Dark Sun? I have no idea what the price of such a feat'd be, mind you.

Furthermore and I really don't like bursting anyone's bubble, but what makes you think this has ANY sort of chance of success?

And let me say right now, so I won't have to in the future: I'm sorry for stepping on anyone's toes.
#51

nightdruid

Dec 14, 2004 13:03:34
Not meaning to break the fun anyone is having with all this, but wouldn't it be easier to simply buy the rights to Dark Sun? I have no idea what the price of such a feat'd be, mind you.

That's an easy answer: nobody has $100,000+ on hand to buy it (probably double or triple that). My understanding is that you'd need at least that much just to get WotC to talk to you about buying it.
#52

Pennarin

Dec 14, 2004 13:11:11
Hey everyone! Torack is donating the money for the DS license!

Long live Torack!! Huray!

Rrrmm...Nightdruid has a more sedate answer.
#53

zombiegleemax

Dec 14, 2004 13:33:23
Torack, what is the point of posting something like that? We're trying to cause something to happen. Wizards won't sell the rights, not even to the original author, because they have plans for the setting, as in movies, probably eventually bringing it back to current rules, etc. We're really just trying to accellerate the process by showing there's a great demand for it now. Negative attitudes like yours detract from what we are trying to do. Also, for every person that signs the pettiton, there's probably 100 who have no idea the petition is out there, or haven't signed cause they're paranoid about getting spam or something, which won't happen. WOTC stands to make a lot of money doing this. I have to speculate about your motives. Are you perhaps a Realms fan? Or really into Eberron?
#54

Kamelion

Dec 14, 2004 14:29:44
Torack, what is the point of posting something like that? We're trying to cause something to happen. Wizards won't sell the rights, not even to the original author, because they have plans for the setting, as in movies, probably eventually bringing it back to current rules, etc. We're really just trying to accellerate the process by showing there's a great demand for it now. Negative attitudes like yours detract from what we are trying to do. Also, for every person that signs the pettiton, there's probably 100 who have no idea the petition is out there, or haven't signed cause they're paranoid about getting spam or something, which won't happen. WOTC stands to make a lot of money doing this. I have to speculate about your motives. Are you perhaps a Realms fan? Or really into Eberron?

Torack is entitled to put his point of view forward, so long as he is civil about it (which I would say he has been), so let's not get worked up about it, eh? For the record, while I wish those who have created and signed this petition all the best of luck, I also have reservations about its success (Mach summed them up quite neatly). But maybe that's a topic for another thread .
#55

jesterjeff

Dec 14, 2004 15:32:17
Torak's right in a sense. This is really just a rallying cry, to tell wizards that there is a strong, active potential customer base for the dark sun setting, We'd prefer that the athas.org version be used over any others but our mian desire is that whatever plans they made in the long run be sped up.

We look to dragonlance and ravenloft as examples of old settings reborn to 3rd and know that DS will sell at least equal to either of these settings, and potentially equal FR in sales revinue. It has a vast unused potential in stories and character designs for video games, books, campaign modules and release books. While Magic is the all time standard 'FX' provided by D&D with psionics as a side, alternate style, in Dark Sun this is reversed.The revised psionics rulebook could be given the oportunity to rise to the occasion and face an upturn in sales as well.


What we do not need is negative reactions to naysayers. They have the right to their opinions, and in fact, these opinions are needed to refine any idea. Otherwise, any intellectual pursuit would stagnate in neglect.
#56

nytcrawlr

Dec 14, 2004 15:34:24
That's an easy answer: nobody has $100,000+ on hand to buy it (probably double or triple that). My understanding is that you'd need at least that much just to get WotC to talk to you about buying it.

Chew on this...

Troy Denning has gone to WotC, TWICE (pay attention will you people), WITH CASH in hopes to purchase Dark Sun and was shot down both times.

So obviously it's not a money issue, there's a much bigger issue going on.
#57

the_peacebringer

Dec 14, 2004 16:15:30
Troy Denning has gone to WotC, TWICE (pay attention will you people), WITH CASH in hopes to purchase Dark Sun and was shot down both times.

So obviously it's not a money issue, there's a much bigger issue going on.

It's a conspiracy, I tell ya!

BTW, I think Kam and Jester are right, this petition alone probably won't do it. Anyways, I'm staying positive but I'm not getting my hopes up.<

P.S. When I signed, we were only three so I can't give you guys THE COUNT :D .
#58

nytcrawlr

Dec 14, 2004 16:34:45
It's a conspiracy, I tell ya!

Not a conspiracy, just proof that WotC has other motives then to just sell it off to the highest bidder.

Don't get me wrong, I signed this petition after all, but I think if you are truly serious about this, then you better be ready for a long, drug out fight, where as this is the only first step of that fight.

If you aren't that serious, then I hope this wasn't too much of a waste of time, heh.
#59

zombiegleemax

Dec 14, 2004 16:38:31
Chew on this...

Troy Denning has gone to WotC, TWICE (pay attention will you people), WITH CASH in hopes to purchase Dark Sun and was shot down both times.

So obviously it's not a money issue, there's a much bigger issue going on.

And did they give more detailed answer or just send Mr Denning away?

When was it? If before Ravenloft and Dragonlace was resurrected by 3rd parties maybe they waited for such thing for DS as well, or contrary, they didn't know what to do with it (=how to make money from it) and simply waited for this very reason.
#60

nytcrawlr

Dec 14, 2004 16:44:18
And did they give more detailed answer or just send Mr Denning away?

Unfortunately that's all the information that I have.

We could always add it to the Q&A, but I don't recommend that. Only because it will probably be ignored at that point.
#61

the_peacebringer

Dec 14, 2004 17:04:39
Not a conspiracy, just proof that WotC has other motives then to just sell it off to the highest bidder.

Don't get me wrong, I signed this petition after all, but I think if you are truly serious about this, then you better be ready for a long, drug out fight, where as this is the only first step of that fight.

If you aren't that serious, then I hope this wasn't too much of a waste of time, heh.

Serious about the conspiracy... no, that was a joke.

But I am serious about helping out if I can... and if it don't cos' nuthin'. Don't get me wrong, if DS comes out, I'll buy it (which is why I signed in the first place), but my life is not depending on it... Besides, I like what you guys at Athas.org and all the fans on this forum are doing (well, the ones that are actually providing something... not fans like I, who just read the stuff :P ).

All in all, whatever happens, I'm stickin'!
#62

Grummore

Dec 14, 2004 18:23:55
Not meaning to break the fun anyone is having with all this, but wouldn't it be easier to simply buy the rights to Dark Sun? I have no idea what the price of such a feat'd be, mind you.

Furthermore and I really don't like bursting anyone's bubble, but what makes you think this has ANY sort of chance of success?

And let me say right now, so I won't have to in the future: I'm sorry for stepping on anyone's toes.

Maybe there is a small chance or no chance at all, but at least we must not stop peoples that are trying. They had the guts to try something, by all means, if it work, cheer!
#63

zombiegleemax

Dec 14, 2004 21:58:29
#64

Torack

Dec 15, 2004 11:46:32
Are you perhaps a Realms fan? Or really into Eberron?

HAHAHAHA! Seriously, if given the choice between Dark Sun and any other campaign out there, I'd pick Dark Sun in a heartbeat(Actually it'd be less then that, but who's counting?).

Sorry to dissapoint you. It's just that I've seen waaaaay to many of these Online Petitions used for all sorts of stuff and none of those had the desired effect.

With regards to the not-selling-the-setting, assuming WotC has plans for it(And I hope they do), wouldn't it be, I don't know, easier to wait see what'll happen?

I know a lot of you, dare I say, like me, really really really really want WotC to publish more material on the settings, and I can imagine that holds true for the folks from Planescape and Mystara and Spelljammer god-knows what other worlds out there got cut.

Personally I consider it a boon to know that settings like Ravenloft and Dragonlance have not dissapeared and made the transition to 3rd Edition/v3.5. It means there's hope for the other settings too.

Meh, but I'm starting to ramble, so I'll just quit now.
#65

nightdruid

Dec 15, 2004 12:05:30
With regards to the not-selling-the-setting, assuming WotC has plans for it(And I hope they do), wouldn't it be, I don't know, easier to wait see what'll happen?

Possibly; more likely they're just sitting on the license. Corperations often do just that: they'll sit on a license for a few years/decades, because either supporting it isn't worth the effort, or hope that the license increases in value.

Best example that I can think of is in action is Star Trek. In the 70s (?), it fairly expensive to produce, costing a huge amount of money per episode, and it had medocre ratings. So the networks canned it after what, 70 episodes, then sat on the license for 10-15 years. During that time, it developed an enormous cult following, such that they decided to bring it back with The Next Generation, which proved successful enough to warrent 3 additional spin-offs. Now, of course, after so many spinoffs that lasted 7 years each, they've managed to run the license pretty much into the ground again. Ratings for Enterprise are rather slim, so I expect them to shove Star Trek into a vault somewhere for the next 10 years, and let the cult regrow.

So I can imagine WotC is either waiting for a time when setting revivals will be profitable. If that's next year or 10 years from now, I really can't say, I'm not a bean-counter
#66

zombiegleemax

Dec 15, 2004 13:01:17
It may not have the greatest chance of success,
But is costs us nothing but a few seconds of effort to try! :D
#67

mr._fixit

Dec 15, 2004 17:45:17
Mr. FIXIT has now signed this petition. He did this because Athas is such a nice place to live if you are an evil wizard like him (oh, and he likes the warm weather as well). ;)
#68

zombiegleemax

Dec 17, 2004 6:47:03
#69

jesterjeff

Dec 17, 2004 9:00:29
good job so far folks. 506 signatures and some good comments as well.
#70

jesterjeff

Dec 17, 2004 20:13:59
520 ladies and gents, spread the word.

oh and in case you don't know the word is 'Loot'.
#71

zombiegleemax

Dec 20, 2004 4:27:14
#72

Torack

Dec 20, 2004 12:32:31
Alright, alright. You guys convinced me. I signed. 588 so far. Let's keep 'em coming guys!
#73

brun01

Dec 20, 2004 13:47:46
Come on, people! We gotta make 1000 signatures before New Year's!!!
#74

jesterjeff

Dec 21, 2004 20:48:42
617 wow this looks like it's coming along nicely. Everyone keep up the good work.
#75

jesterjeff

Dec 23, 2004 16:34:49
646
or in other words
BUMP
#76

jon_oracle_of_athas

Dec 23, 2004 16:47:04
Have you posted the petition on other forums such as enworld.org or rpg.net?
#77

jesterjeff

Dec 23, 2004 16:53:43
other sections here and planet Ad&D. didn't know about enworld and forgot rpg


damn. I hate it when I rhyme, sad to say I do it all the time
#78

nytcrawlr

Dec 23, 2004 17:01:35
I bet you'll get it closer to 1,000 if you post to those two communities.

#79

Pennarin

Dec 23, 2004 22:48:25
660.
Damn, I nearly made 666.
Shoo.
#80

jon_oracle_of_athas

Dec 26, 2004 12:33:01
I bet you'll get it closer to 1,000 if you post to those two communities.

Yes. You should post there.
#81

twelvedrunkenmonkeyz

Dec 26, 2004 14:25:03
I think that the people at Athas.org did a good job as well, but I had just started playing D&D and buying books (which burned up in a house fire) when TSR went belly-up. So I to am writing here and would like to say that in my opinion DS and Birthright where 2 of my favorite settings. I suprised that they wouldn't release anything for DS either as it was one of the totally unique setting and one of the grittiest as well. Now they seem to have replaced it with Eberron as the new gritty setting. Well LONG LIVE THE MULS!
#82

jesterjeff

Dec 26, 2004 15:12:11
I don't see Eberron as a Gritty setting, more of a film noir Pulp Novelized setting. You play Eberron topop out a few neo-fantasy/steamerpunk characters and adventures. It's more of a 'The Shadow' and 'Indiana jones' Style characters.

Dark Sun is a more gritty setting. and that's being literal. Sorry I can't help it sometimes.
DS offers you a chance to play either with a post apocalyptic or primatives stance. While Eberron gives you a stylistic expansion of racial and class stereotypes DS gives you a completely different story. Where you blend palace intrigue and savage adventure with a real challenge; survival.
#83

brun01

Dec 28, 2004 8:34:02
718!!!

#84

jon_oracle_of_athas

Dec 28, 2004 17:22:44
Looking good.
#85

jesterjeff

Dec 28, 2004 21:53:58
726
Yes, we're coming along nicely. another few weeks I might have enough to comfortablely send it off to the wiz' staff...
#86

jesterjeff

Jan 02, 2005 12:03:34
763

Happy BUMPING New Year!
#87

zombiegleemax

Jan 02, 2005 19:38:10
#88

johndoe

Jan 03, 2005 0:35:17
signed sealed delivered.
but please get Brom back to do more artwork if stuff does get published :D

oh btw, this might be against privacy rules, but i saw some dutch names in that list of people that signed the petition, and since im still looking for more people in my own country to maybe hook up with or at least chatter with about Dark Sun, is there any chance they could either speak up here on the forum or people point me out to them or them to me or whatever :P :D
#89

jon_oracle_of_athas

Jan 03, 2005 8:49:20
Jeff, Terminus, have you posted the link to the petition on Enworld and Rpg.net yet? If not, give it a whirl. You could get a lot of new signatures.
#90

zombiegleemax

Jan 03, 2005 9:27:42
Posting is Jeff's department. Mine is hype, silencing nay-sayers, and real-world promotion with my Delegate activities, which will be commencing soon. I'll let him know about your idea, though.
#91

jesterjeff

Jan 03, 2005 10:09:35
i posted in enworld, but have been unable to get a membership on rpg, so if someone else wouldn't mine posting there I'd apprieciate it.
#92

flip

Jan 03, 2005 14:34:20
What do you mean?? He lost is power from wotc? Why?

Did you note the new board software? Some of the, erm, admin features for those of us in ... er, non-standard admin groups, are currently not implemented.

I never had the rights of a full admin/moderator, and at the moment, with the new software, I'm even more restricted than I once was ...
#93

jon_oracle_of_athas

Jan 03, 2005 19:32:07
The two of us should talk to the Wiz-O's about getting those priveleges.
#94

flip

Jan 03, 2005 19:43:32
The two of us should talk to the Wiz-O's about getting those priveleges.

it's a matter of hacking the board code. Really, all I can do is post polls and close/reopen my own threads. I have to beg to get something stickied.
#95

jesterjeff

Jan 08, 2005 22:40:57
811 signatures right now.

So What's the general consensus on the signature number i'm looking for before printing this and sending it to the customer service dept, marketing dept, sales, and what corollates to a games development devision of Wizards?

i'd hate to send this off before as many people as possible have a chance to sign and make themselves heard.
#96

jaanos

Jan 09, 2005 21:42:44
10,000??? ask the dragonlance people....they may be able to give you an accurate figure...
#97

nytcrawlr

Jan 10, 2005 16:09:58
I'd wait till you have this up to at least 1,000.

Now that you have it both on enworld and rpg it should be getting a ton of new sigs.
#98

zombiegleemax

Jan 12, 2005 18:29:50
829 Total Signatures

come on guys get ya friends to sign, find dark sun fan sites and spam them with the petition, everything we can do to get it goin!
#99

dawnstealer

Jan 12, 2005 19:05:42
I signed it.

So What's the general consensus on the signature number i'm looking for before printing this and sending it to the customer service dept, marketing dept, sales, and what corollates to a games development devision of Wizards?

I would aim for at least 3,000 signatures, and that's a minimum. Basically, what you are doing is giving Wizards a document that says, "This many people will buy your product if you actually release it." It has to be a number that would justify them roping in artists, writers, editors, and so on. If 3,000 sign a document, that's a sizeable number. Otherwise, the costs just do not justify it.

Now, release it to another corp? That's a better idea. Will they do it? Unlikely, but what've we got to lose?

Personally, I like the job Athas.org is doing, but something more concrete (ie. non-voluntary) would be nice.
#100

jesterjeff

Jan 12, 2005 19:11:35
I would aim for at least 3,000 signatures, and that's a minimum. Basically, what you are doing is giving Wizards a document that says, "This many people will buy your product if you actually release it." It has to be a number that would justify them roping in artists, writers, editors, and so on. If 3,000 sign a document, that's a sizeable number. Otherwise, the costs just do not justify it.

makes sense.
So Everyone, keep passing this link around to friends, gamers. print the front page and some blank sheets and take em to your gaming shops...

chop chop people. I want a new book for next Christmas. :D
#101

jesterjeff

Jan 19, 2005 20:37:16
850 signatures. BUMP. Come on folks pass the word around.
#102

dawnstealer

Jan 19, 2005 23:29:29
Awwwww...

Somebody needs some cotton candy!



And a cheerleader!



And, uh, one of these!

:coolcthul
#103

zombiegleemax

Jan 21, 2005 22:51:43
Personally, and yes, I'm my usual pessemistic self here, I think 3k is a rather low number. Even assuming that the online fanbase only represents 10% (which is what the friends I have in the business community tell me is generally a good way to match things, and which is also the reason why companies see online groups as a vocal minority) of the total market, you still don't really come up with a decent number of potential customers. 30,000 fans at 3k signatures. Now, look at it through Wizard's eyes: 30,000 fans wanting DS. 75% will purchase the core book. 30% will purchase one or two supplements or adventures, 3-4 total. 10% will likely purchase every product. That's not a heck of a lot of sales, especially when it comes to continuation of the setting line in the long run. Signatures aside though, I'm kinda curious if Flip could in some way toss out something about how many times the Corerules pdf has been downloaded (maybe even taking into account some odd number of people downloading it multiple times) as a framework for how many potential online customers there are.

Maybe I'm offbase. Maybe 20,000 plus core book sales is enough to get WOTC's attention. Hopefully so.

:coolcthul (sorry, just had to use a cthulhu smily)
#104

dawnstealer

Jan 21, 2005 23:12:02
Yar, I tend to agree: 3,000 being a minimum. 3,000 might be enough for someone at Wizards to take a closer look and do some "market research," however. Now the next question: would you rather put Dark Sun into the hands of Wizards or keep it right here in the community, where you actually have a say in what happens.

I know where I'd rather have it.
#105

zombiegleemax

Jan 22, 2005 0:07:36
A split decision.

On one hand, I'd rather keep it free, available to all, outside the constraints of a 'publisher's opinion' of how to make a product sell, and best of all, be able to offer feedback, citiques, and criticism about what goes on.

On the other hand, it sure as hell would be nice to see WOTC throw Athas.org a bone for the years of hard work. I don't care about holding some damn hardcover book in my hands; its the information itself I'm after, not the 8x10 glossy pic on an overpriced coffee coaster. In reality, if WOTC revived DS, or some other publisher, but cut Athas.org and the online community out of the picture, I probably would regret having signed the petition.

In fact . . . if anyone at marketing had half a brain, they would realise quickly the push factor of reviving a setting such as DS or PS WITH the community involvement. "You designed it; we made it reality" or somesuch catchy nonesensical selling point. Reviewed and critiqed by the fanbase itself before seeing print. If, and that's one hell of an unlikely IF, they took that kind of direction with it, then I'd stand up and support it 100%. Liscensing aside, I still feel like DS has become OUR setting now, even if we don't own it. Kinda like finding a lovable freindly stray dog and raising it for a few years, only to have the real dog's owner come back and take it off you, turn it into a viscious attack dog, and then saying 'how do you like him now?'

I'd still like to see Athas.org get something for the work involved . . . at least offer to foot the bill for hosting or something.
#106

dawnstealer

Jan 22, 2005 1:29:27
Not to be too negative, but don't bet the house on it. Expect something more along the lines of Pazio's (?) Athas. Not bad, but not what we all see as "right."
#107

Kamelion

Jan 22, 2005 7:15:48
Yar, I tend to agree: 3,000 being a minimum. 3,000 might be enough for someone at Wizards to take a closer look and do some "market research," however. Now the next question: would you rather put Dark Sun into the hands of Wizards or keep it right here in the community, where you actually have a say in what happens.

I know where I'd rather have it.

Amen to that .
#108

zombiegleemax

Jan 22, 2005 14:25:39
After careful consideration, I think you guys may be right. Athas is right where it belongs. I mean, if Wizards did revive it, unless they kept Athas.org in the loop, we'd have no voice and they probably would tone down and dilute the setting. That's kinda why the petition states that we'd like them to include athas.org in the development. Also, big companies don't really care what we think, they only care what will sell, and they're probably going to hold out on a published hardcover version of Dark Sun until people finally get sick of the Realms and Eberron. We'll just have to wait and see, but I guess for now, that's all, folks.
#109

irongolem

Jan 23, 2005 9:11:04


I am all for this.
#110

nytcrawlr

Jan 24, 2005 14:40:06
Now the next question: would you rather put Dark Sun into the hands of Wizards or keep it right here in the community, where you actually have a say in what happens.

I know where I'd rather have it.

Amen brother.

Until I get my Troy, Tim, Melka, and Abbey dream team to do DS, I'd rather keep it in the commnity's hands.